All episodes

Ganesh Balakrishnan
on Momoe and Flatheads

Episode
02
Released
Length
75 min
Recorded live at
MIT WPU, Pune

The story

Ganesh Balakrishnan co-founded Momoe, a mobile payments startup, and Flatheads, a shoe brand. He studied at IIT Bombay and IIM Bangalore. He then spent 15 years in corporate jobs, including Bain and Honeywell. He met his co-founder at Honeywell and resigned the day he decided to start Momoe. He also appeared on Shark Tank India.

Momoe let people pay by phone at restaurants and shops. It also powered the first toll road in India to take digital payments. About 65% of its payments went through, when others managed about 30%. But Momoe had raised $1.2 million, while Paytm had $600 million. Then UPI launched with zero MDR, the small fee a business pays on each digital payment. Momoe's main income fell to zero. Rather than shut down, Momoe was acquired by ShopClues. Ganesh then helped grow its merchants from 1.5 lakh to about 5.5 lakh.

Flatheads made comfortable shoes for long work days. It launched in November 2019, and COVID hit in March 2020. Each time monthly sales reached ₹50 lakh, a new wave pushed them back to zero. An investor told him to keep the money in the bank and take a two-year break. He did not listen, and now says he should have. The talk also covers leaving a job, pitching to investors, and AI.

Key lessons

  • FOMO, the fear of missing out, is a fine reason to start. But it only lasts until the first hurdle, and after that you need conviction and problem solving.

    Watch at 18:45
  • Start with a problem people feel every day. Momoe was built to end long waits at bill counters and toll booths, not just to process payments.

    Watch at 28:06
  • In tech, markets usually end with two or three big players, so being early and growing fast matters. For a consumer brand, a clear niche matters more.

    Watch at 47:32
  • Get introduced to investors through people you know, then let them try the product. Momoe's investors saw their own restaurant bill on their phone, with no slides needed.

    Watch at 59:48
  • Sometimes stopping for a while is the better choice. Looking back, Ganesh says he should have followed his investor's advice to pause Flatheads for two years.

    Watch at 1:07:15

In Ganesh's words

I did not listen to him. If I had to go back and do it, I would have done it very differently. I would have taken that 2-year holiday.

Ganesh Balakrishnan, at 0:43

At some point in time, the decision became, hey, you know what? Either we die or we get acquired and build scale within that platform.

Ganesh Balakrishnan, at 53:08

Every time we hit 50 lakhs, we went to zero again. So we had to start from scratch again.

Ganesh Balakrishnan, at 1:05:10

Full transcript

Made from YouTube's automatic captions and lightly edited. Speaker names are not marked, and there may be small errors.

Show transcriptHide transcript

0:00Every time we hit 50 lakhs, we went to zero again. So I had no thought of entrepreneurship at all. What went wrong with that thought? I came from a very small town. I grew up in Nashik, by the way. We came in and we funded you because of one reason, and that reason is you have no idea what you're doing.

0:18Who is your favorite shark, and who is your favorite shark?

0:20I think for that perspective, I personally like Anupam. What about you?

0:23I like thinking that he has with a company that has raised 1.2 million.

0:30How do you compete with somebody who has raised 600 million?

0:35Either we die or we get acquired and build scale within that platform. First wave hit, sales went to zero.

0:41Flatheads.

0:42Bad timing.

0:43Do something else. Take a 2-year holiday. Come back 2 years later. Then you can start building. I did not listen to him. If I had to go back and do it, I would have done it very differently. I would have taken that 2-year holiday. So by the way, Ganesh is a IIT Mumbai alumni in engineering, refrigeration engineering, the cool guy, right? And Ganesh has completed his masters from IIM Bangalore. Now having said this thing, Ganesh, when you entered into your first year of engineering, I'm quite sure you would have your own thoughts, what you wanted to do with your life. What was the plan back then? How would these next 10 to 15 years after IIT Bombay be for you?

1:30Interesting question. So when I was in IIT, I didn't even know this word called entrepreneurship, to be honest. I came from a very small town. I grew up in Nashik, by the way. So and I did my 11th and 12th in Orissa. So very small town, nearest city was 6 hours away, right? So walking into a big campus like IIT Bombay itself was a big, you know, achievement as such. My objective was to just go and join, you know, a company, a good company, right? Or, you know, sometime during my journey in IIT Bombay, I realized that, hey, there are, you know, options for further studies as well. So the option was, you know, go and specialize in refrigeration, which was something that I really liked, which a lot of people didn't like in mechanical engineering, by the way. But that was something, that topic, that was really interesting for me. So I thought, you know, maybe I can pursue something in that direction as well. So I had no thought of entrepreneurship at all. It was either the corporate life or, you know, further studies. That's what I had in mind, to be honest.

2:48That's a quite stable approach towards life.

2:51And that brings me to my first question. What went wrong with that thought?

2:58So I was part of the corporate workforce for 15 years. You saw that graph there, right? So joining Allied, and after doing my masters in refrigeration, so did refrigeration for, you know, five years, set up their engineering center in Bangalore, then did my MBA, joined Bain and Company, which is a strategy consulting firm, and then did corporate strategy at Honeywell as well. So I did my fair share of corporate experience as well. It is a transition from going from a corporate journey. One thing that I noticed was I was drawn towards entrepreneurial ventures, right? So even in the large companies, I tended to go towards places where there were small initiatives happening, micro businesses being developed, right? Like, for example, Ingosol brand is a massive company, US-based, right? I worked there for, you know, three and a half, four years, but at the end of my stint there, I had a choice to either continue in the, you know, corporate world there, which is a large office, you know, thousands of employees, these kind of organization, or start the engineering center back in Bangalore. They were just starting an engineering center there, like global cap GCCs, they call it now, right? Global capital centers. It was one of the early ones in 2004. That appealed to me a lot more than actually working in the large corporate because, number one, I had the autonomy and the freedom to do something from scratch. It sounded very exciting. And second, it would probably give me a lot more experience on a broader level of what a business is. I was an engineer otherwise, right? So I was sitting in a workshop. I was sitting in an R&D lab. I was building products and prototyping products. I understood the engineering aspect of things. But there was something about the business aspect which I was very curious about, and that is where I jumped in there.

5:16From there, then, you know, post MBA, joined Bain. Bain was a very small organization. It was 20 people in Delhi, right, versus the McKinsey and the BCG, which were much larger. But had the opportunity to go and join the early office in Bain and see the consulting practice being built out, right? So that was another, you know, almost a mini startup kind of an experience. The third was in Honeywell as well. We were building the entire local business portfolio for Honeywell in India and Southeast Asia, based on core Honeywell technologies, which are, you know, century old. But what was the local use case in India? How can those products and price points be adopted for the Indian use cases, right? So that was the, and we built a proper $250 million portfolio, out of which, you know, almost half of it went live, right, and are existing businesses today.

6:15So great opportunity to understand the Indian context, business, build a business use case, business, build a business model and launch it in the market, right? So there was an end-to-end experience that I got. So while I was doing this corporate thing, I always had this thing for entrepreneurial ventures, right?

6:32Right.

6:32And then I said, yeah, if I can do this inside the company. Incidentally, I met my co-founder in Honeywell. We worked together, right? And that's another big spark, right, where when we said, hey, you know, we usually used to take our chai breaks together, right, and sit and talk about, you know, what's happening in the world of entrepreneurship. Bangalore has this little bit of entrepreneurship blood in the air, right? It's in the air, it's in the weather, it's So we used to talk about it quite a bit, and eventually I just frucified to a point where I said, you know what, there is something that I'm very excited about. It is something that I want to build. I'm not sure I can build it inside the company. Why don't I go. He said, "Yeah, sounds like a good plan." But a lot of conversations happen like that, right? I'm sure a lot of people sitting in offices are having this conversation every day during their chai breaks. But one thing happened differently, and that different thing was I went and put my resignation that day because I was so convinced about the idea that we were going to work on. He was shocked. My co-founder was shocked. How did that happen? We just had this conversation. Where did this come from?

7:42And you resigned.

7:42I resigned. Yeah. I felt so passionate about it and convinced about it that this will work that I just said, you know, it's worth quitting the job and going. Of course, there's a lot of You might think about it, something about what was that discussion in that intellectually stimulated chai break of yours?

8:02No, it wasn't one chai break. It was over a period of time.

8:05But the whole idea was, 3G was just launching in India, as you mentioned, right? So the ecosystem of phones became smartphones, that was exploding. Most of you were probably not born yet at that time, but, oh no, you might have been born, but you may not realize this yet, but just 13 years ago, smartphones were very new in the market in India, and data was barely enough for you to, you know, stream a low resolution video or upload pictures, right? So that ecosystem was exploding, and it just felt like there is a huge space for the transaction economy to happen, right? So my co-founder is a designer. So his mind is all about consumer behavior, right? That's how he thinks. And whenever we used to go to China, we used to see people using phones to pay, right? And Alipay and WeChat Pay were big ecosystems already building out there, growing ecosystem, right? And that just blew our mind. When we went to a shop, they would say no Visa, which means no cards accepted, right?

9:14Right. You can pay with your phone, and people would literally pay with their phone, which was unbelievable for us, right? We said, hey, if this is possible here, and we are, in terms of consumer density, in terms of consumer behavior, it's very similar, we follow that kind of a market, right?

9:33We said, hey, this is an eventual reality that we're going to have. So after our, you know, one week we used to have these strategy emotion sessions in China, China and Shanghai. And once we saw this, we said, yeah, this is something that we should build. And then we've had multiple conversations around it. Me being a consultant, I have done, you know, research on what the market is around the world, who are all doing it, what's happening, all those things we used to talk about doing these chai breaks. And eventually it came to a point where we said, nobody's doing this, why can't we do this? And that day I put in my papers, right?

10:07Okay.

10:09And yeah, one thing led to another. He put in his papers 15 days later. Both of us took off and started Momoe, right? So that was a conversation.

10:17So then, one thing from my side. If you put in your papers, right, what was the savings amount that you had in your bank account that time? Because for me right now, I don't have a figure in my mind if I want to start my own company. So should there be a figure, or is it just like, you know what, I might not have that money, but still go for it? I think situations are very different from then to now, but I'll tell you my perspective, right? So as long as you have, like I had, like my wife was earning, right? So if you have some sort of financial income that is coming into your home, right?

10:59Then a, I don't know, 12 months window or right, of finances that you can shore up is good to start, right? In that 12 months, you should be able to figure out whether your business is viable or not.

11:12Right. So I gave myself 18 months.

11:14So I had a little more buffer in that sense.

11:16And of course, my wife was supportive about it, right? I said that in Shark Tank as well, like, right, so I have been trying to show that to my wife since then. She's not watching the video only.

11:30So that ideally would be a financial cushion that you want to look at.

11:35Also, it depends on how much, what do you call it, liabilities you have, right? At that time we had a home loan, and hence I had to plan for a longer period of time, right?

11:45I mean, you're a bachelor, you don't have any, you know, nothing on the time.

11:50Probably a student loan. Correct. So you just have to think about that liability and accordingly plan your cushion, right?

11:55And the other thing you learn is, as entrepreneurs, you know this, you learn to live within your means, right? You're saying, We will live with this, right? Yeah. And that comes naturally.

12:09I'll add my two cents to what Ganesh said. You cannot have this thing predefined, key. I have 12 months runway, I have 18 months runway, or I have 6 months runway, because you never know. When you are building, there is no timeline attached to building a product. Six month product can take even six years to click in the market, right? So I think intention is something that will drive you, or any of the people who are willing to do that.

12:37True. Very true. So just linking to the thing that you just said about education zones right now, right? You graduated from IIT Bombay, and the salary and the fees out there, the education fees, is quite less as compared to private colleges today. So do you think the pressure of paying an exorbitant amount of fees in private colleges is also a reason why people in private colleges might not opt for entrepreneurship early on? Very distinct possibility, for sure. Right? Ultimately, you are thinking about and you are worried about the financial aspect, you know, of how this is going to go. I'll put a counterpoint to that.

13:26Okay.

13:26Let me say the cost of starting up in today's world, if you're not building a, you know, physical product, if you're building a tech product, the cost of starting up is literally zero.

13:39Right.

13:39Right. It costs nothing for you to build something and launch it in the market and test it as a tech product.

13:47Correct.

13:47Right. So from my perspective, if I had to build Momoe out at that time, the cost of building that involved getting like a proper tech team and building the product out, right? And then going to the market is a separate conversation altogether, right?

14:03But right now, if I have to build it, I don't know anything about coding, I can still build that stack because I have an AI assistant with me which can actually build that entire thing out, right? At least from a proof of concept perspective, from an MVP perspective, the cost of doing that is zero.

14:18So I don't see any excuse for anybody who wants to get started from a financial restriction perspective.

14:25You can launch your MVP and see if it is work, you know, whether it has legs or not with virtually no expense at all.

14:32Correct.

14:33Right. So I'm just saying that if the intent is there, just like what Koustubh was saying, if the intent is there, you can find a way. When there is a will, there is a way. You can find a way around it, right? And the family and friends financial support ecosystem that we had is very different from what this generation has. I think income levels have gone up. The number of people who are ready to support entrepreneurship has gone up. The understanding of, you know, starting up is not taboo anymore. Right? So even if you don't have your own finances, you can find people around you who believe in what you're trying to do, or at least believe in you, in order to give you that seed money to go and do something out there.

15:20Well said. Well said. So Ganesh, again, let's go back to your IIT days. So just let's finish the college thing first and then move to Momoe and Flatheads. I have given more founders than engineers. I personally feel that. So most of the people, especially starting up, most of the unicorns if you see in the market, most of the funded startup people have really gone all in when it comes to, when they move out from IIT and startup. What goes wrong at IIT that it pushes, literally pushes, sensible people to move from a stable life in front of them?

15:59I like the fact that you said sensible people. So people who start up are not sensitive.

16:04Oh, that's too outrageous.

16:07See, when you're in a group of people who are mostly smarter than you are, that is the environment in which I went into when I was in IIT, right? You can actually challenge yourself to do much more than what you actually believe that you were capable of before you walked in there. Right? So when you bring that kind of a smart ecosystem together, and by the way, it is not an IIT phenomenon, it's any college phenomenon now, right? If you're able to find people around you who have similar thinking in order to do things from an entrepreneurial perspective, things just move in that direction, right? In IIT Bombay that time, there was Simon, which was the incubator, business incubator, right, that was just started during our time there. Obviously that was Y2K. So there were a lot of incubations of, you know, IT services kind of businesses as well. But that support ecosystem started building in the IIT much earlier because there were enough alumni who had contributed and were willing to do that inside the campus in terms of setting up that incubation, and that happened across other IITs as well, not just Bombay, right. So there is one support ecosystem there. You have a set of smart people, if you, and at that time you have nothing but ideas, right? Your mind is open and you can do whatever. You don't have any constraints in thinking, you don't have any emotional baggage, you can just go and do what you want to do, right? And there is always that sense of why can't I change the world, right? That is the youthful exuberance that you have.

17:48Right. So when all those things come together, and then you see a lot of for seniors as well going and doing entrepreneurial stuff and building businesses, that also acts as a lot of motivation for people, right? So that ecosystem builds over time, right? What started when I was there in 95 is now becoming a full-blown You know, ecosystem as in, when more people are graduating, more people are building businesses, that knowledge transfer is happening, people are willing to come back and, you know, train the next set of people, teach the next set of people, give them that motivation, give them the funds to start up. That's how it moves, right? So that's the flywheel that has been built over time.

18:31No, I agree with this point. But then in today's age, FOMO is something that is going on a lot.

18:39Yeah.

18:39In the building culture. So do you think a lot of things are being developed out of this FOMO culture?

18:45Possible. You may start with FOMO as the reason. It's something that will sustain you for, like, curiosity and FOMO will sustain you until the first hurdle you hit, and that hurdle will come very quickly, right? Beyond the first set of people who know you, who are willing to try your product, solution, whatever you're building, right, the next set of people that you go to, immediately you will hit that hurdle, right? For will sustain you until that point, but beyond that, if you really have to progress, then there is a lot more to it. You need to have a lot more conviction. You need to have a lot bigger vision of how this will go. You need to understand problem solving. You need to understand how to deal with those kind of situations where those hurdles will come. That conviction stays beyond FOMO, right? FOMO is a great way to start. I will not say that FOMO is the wrong thing to do, the wrong thing to start up. Please go ahead, start, and then once you hit those hurdles, be, you know, persevering, understand how to build beyond the hurdles that you see. That is where entrepreneurial spirit starts happening, right?

20:03True.

20:04Yeah, there is nothing wrong with FOMO.

20:07FOMO is human nature, right?

20:09For a very long time, if I ever had FOMO, it was because of Ganesh.

20:15I'm not joking, I have a story behind this. When you were building Momoe, you were in the restaurant space, payments you started. That Ressy was into the restaurant space as well. We were into capacity planning for restaurants, and then when I saw what Momoe was doing, enabling payments over there, for me it was a cakewalk just because I had someone to look up to, right? Har there is a company which has done this thing, we have around 2,000 restaurants, we should start that. Then it moved to, they partnered with RBL for wallet, again a FOMO on my side. I'm not partnering with banks. Then we started powering HDFC, IDBI, Bank of Ara. Then the next thing was getting acquired, again a FOMO. How is it that this is happening?

20:54Then I started following the same path. But Ganesh has given me the maximum fears when we were building Ressy and Momoe at the same time. Okay, let's talk more about Momoe. Let today's generation understand more about that visionary thought process that you said. So you said that going to China changed your thinking about how payments would be processed in the next few years in India.

21:18Correct.

21:19Now tell us more about that point of time when it came to building such a technological product, wherein there were no advances being made in offline transactions as such. I remember Paytm and MobiKwik were there that point of time, but only online, only online. There was no presence of offline ever before you started. So can you just tell us, run us through that particular story from China to coming to India, understanding the technological ecosystem over here, building the product and connecting these dots.

21:48Sure. I mean, take yourself back to 2013. Okay. Not where you are right now. Online payments did not exist. Mobile phones were just starting to have apps. 3G was just launched. 3G was a big deal. Now we are in 5G, but yeah, at that time, you know, the state-of-the-art technology was 3G. In that environment, so my co-founder Utkash is from the design background, so he comes from understanding deep consumer insights, consumer trends and so on. I come from a business background. So I come from understanding market size, understanding industry trends and technology trends that are going on. Right? So you merge these two thought processes. So there is one side, consumer behaviors that are changing, on the other side, industry and technology that is changing, at that intersection.

22:44You will find a lot of interesting things that are happening. Right. So consumer trends is people are now starting to browse on the internet using their phones.

22:53Right.

22:54Right. So first it is information, entertainment comes next.

23:00Right.

23:00Then comes transaction, then commerce starts happening on the phone. Right? That is the journey of the internet in general. Information consumption, transaction, transaction, that's the way it goes. Right?

23:14We saw that on the web, and it was starting to happen on the phone. Right? Combine that with the fact that 3G has come, right, technology is changing, smartphones are changing. Now you have an intersection of something very interesting that's going to happen, which is mobile transactions, right?

23:34Eventually that is going to be a reality because we saw that in China, right?

23:38Incidentally, across the world nobody else was doing this. Google had a Google wallet pilot that they did in New Zealand and Australia, did not work very well, so they were still experimenting on what to do. Apple had partnered with Starbucks for doing their, you know, mobile ordering and payment.

23:57That was the one pilot that was running well, right? Square was the payment instrument that they had used, right? People used to load money on the Amazon, on the Apple wallet, and used to pay before they got to the Starbucks where you can pick up your coffee. So the coffee was ready, you could just pick up and walk out. That was what they were doing. The other thing that we found from a problem statement was, everybody of you shops, right? Everybody of you goes to restaurants.

24:24Correct? Once you have gone to a restaurant with your friends and you're hanging out, you've done your, you know, starters, main course, desserts, and you're at the end of it. You have had your experience, you've had fun with everybody. The time it comes to pay, right? When you're going to pay now, think about 2013, okay? This is how it used to work. You will call the waiter and you will say, "Bring me the bill." The waiter will take 5 to 10 minutes to go and bring the bill. Right? Number one. Number two, once the bill comes, you will say, "Hey, we have five of us. We want to split the bill. Here are four credit cards and here is the fifth person's cash." Now, imagine a waiter having to do the math of splitting the bill across so many things.

25:12And by the way, there were no wireless POS machines at that time, right?

25:16The guy would say, "Sir, please come to the billing counter.

25:19I will swipe your credit card. You have to enter your PIN." And that's where the transaction will go through.

25:23Right?

25:23So this is the second step. From there, four of you have to go with your credit cards to the counter. You will pay.

25:31Right? That entire time in a busy Friday evening, on a busy Friday evening, will take at least 15 minutes.

25:39Correct.

25:39You've had your fun.

25:41Right.

25:41But because they are inefficient in terms of accepting the money that you want to pay.

25:46Exactly.

25:47You are taking extra 15 minutes.

25:48Correct. How many of you have stood in a line in a supermarket? I know a lot of them are online now, but every time you're done with your shopping, your shopping is going to the aisles, picking out what you want and putting them in your cart.

26:01You're done once your cart is full.

26:03Yeah. Right.

26:04After that, that entire process of standing in line for the billing to happen.

26:08Painful. It's painful.

26:09It is super painful. You've done your enjoyable part. That part is inefficiency of the store which you are getting punished for. Why? That is a huge problem that we had, we thought, right?

26:23Why can't we solve this problem? Can we build a seamless checkout in such a way that you are sitting at your place, you keep seeing your bill while you're having fun, while you're ordering things, whenever you want to pay, you just, the mobile is with you, you pay using your mobile, they get an alert that the payment is done, and you just walk out. Why do you have to wait 15 minutes at a retail store? Why can't it be in such a way that as soon as I'm done with my cart, I just leave the cart somewhere, right?

26:55They will do the billing. They will send me the bill. I just pay with my mobile and then someone comes to me. Why can't it be that?

27:02It's such a, now that you think about it, it's such an obvious solution. Right. And it's a much better experience as a customer. I'm in a toll road. Every time you walk in, you go into a toll, there is a line.

27:13Right.

27:14Right. And imagine at that time when, you know, RFID did not exist, fast did not exist. It was all cash.

27:21You will have to give them cash. 23 rupees will be the toll of 23 rupees. Who has changed for 23 rupees?

27:27And was that the same time when they used to return you in chocolates?

27:30Yeah. Yeah. It was my Yeah. Correct.

27:34So at the toll you will give 30 rupees instead of 23. Seven rupees they will not have. Right.

27:39So they will give you chocolates. Your bag, if you're a daily commuter on a toll road, your bag will be laptop and chocolates, that's all there, obviously, right? It is such a pain. You cannot give back chocolate as currency. It is just sitting with you, you're not going to eat those chocolates, right? It is just, it's a big problem because this transaction is happening with cash.

28:02Every transaction takes at least 2 minutes, at least, right?

28:06Multiply it by the number of people in the queue, that is the amount of time that you will have to stand in the toll. Every toll was such a pain to go through. Why can't you just make it seamless? Just go to the toll, automatically the money gets deducted. You drive through, like what fast is now. I'm talking 2013, right? All these are inefficiencies that you can solve for was our thought process. So we came to build Momoe to solve the checkout problem, not the payment problem.

28:35Got it. So but tell me one thing, Anish. When you were building this thing, there is one aspect of technology and the network coming into play. 2012, 13 were those days when you enter a restaurant, you take five to six steps inside, you lose the network, right? That used to be a big challenge back then.

28:55How did you think that, okay, this network challenge can be addressed in next few years, or you had this conviction that okay, from 3G we are going to move to 5G in next 3, 4. What was that conviction like?

29:08Because those things, right?

29:10I don't think we thought that far ahead, to be honest. Okay.

29:12Right. We started with saying we are going to solve this checkout problem. This is our vision. Right. And we built an MVP. We built a basic solution that with your mobile phone's location told you which restaurant you're in, or suggested the three restaurants which are nearby. You can pick the restaurant you're in. You could give your phone number to the waiter. We had built an integration into the billing system so that you could see the bill live on your phone. Right. And that was magic at that time. Right.

29:42Right. The fact that the bill comes on your phone is magic. Right. People were literally blown away. Even the restauranters were like, "What the hell? How did this come?" Right. Including investors. That's how we got our funding as well. But the thought process was not, all right, what are we going to do with this big hurdle on our way. We said, yeah, okay, so internet is a problem inside the restaurant, let us go and find, you know, Hathway. Hathway was the internet provider at that time. We went and talked to Hathway and we said, you know what, if the restaurant is okay, will you come and install Wi-Fi inside. So we actually partnered with the cable operator or the internet operator at that time to go to restaurants and sell Wi-Fi along with our solution.

30:28Okay.

30:28Right. So we were enabling Wi-Fi, free Wi-Fi, inside restaurants at that time.

30:33So we built a business model around that too for the restaurant owners. Right. So there are solutions possible for friction points or, you know, hurdles that you encounter along the way if your vision is something that, you know, you're going to build for, right? So we never thought about this until we walked into the restaurant and realized that there's no network, and that is when we thought about the solution, right? So things move when you are thinking creatively about problem solving along the way.

31:04Right. Speaking about futuristic things, UPI today feels boringly normal, right? But in 2013, it was the future, something that only a few founders envisioned. What are the top three trends specifically today that you think are going to be very much normal in the years to come?

31:26Interesting. Everybody talks about AI, so let me bring that up first. I honestly think that careers are a thing of the past.

31:42Okay.

31:44Everybody is going to be an entrepreneur from now on.

31:47There are the kind of jobs that used to exist for our generation or even the previous generations, don't, will not exist anymore. Everybody will be responsible for their own income, their own way to build their micro business as such. This is going to be a world of freelancers according to me. This is going to be a world of gig economy. People will do things with the aid of AI. What, like, I was in a consulting organization, right? If I have to solve a business case, I will need one partner, one manager, partner to take care of the client relationship, one manager to manage the team and deliver the project, scope out and deliver the project. Consultants who will actually work on individual parts of that business case, and then there will be business analysts who are sitting there analyzing data, going and doing research and coming up with insights which then builds the business solution.

32:47Right. Correct. This was a team of at least six people, five or six people that would go for every business case as a consultant. Now, one person can do this, right? What used to take us three months can be done in a week because all these things, business analysts, don't exist anymore.

33:03Okay?

33:04Right? My wife works in a driver assistance systems company.

33:09Okay?

33:09Which is ADAS they're called. It's basically all the things that you see on your car dashboard, right, in terms of, you know, automatic parking, Yes.

33:22lane departure warning, right, automatic braking for safety, all that stuff. So she works on, her company has not hired coders in the last two years.

33:33Wow, surprising.

33:34Because they have completely integrated AI into their workflow. They are hiring domain experts who understand the automotive aspect of how the system works. They are not hiring entry-level coders anymore because all the coding is being done by AI. They are only giving the right inputs and the prompts and checking the code, of course. Right.

33:54Correct.

33:54So that's where this world is going.

33:58I am saying that that consulting organization can be one person. Now everybody will find their niche and start building their own personal, you know, AI co-pilot, and you will expand your own business much beyond what regular consulting organizations were built to do. You will be a freelancer who is building your own business. That's the way I see the world going forward. Right? Number one, in terms of just careers. Number two, thankfully I come from an engineering and product and manufacturing background. Manufacturing is going to be sexy again. It is the one thing that I don't think AI can do yet.

34:39Correct. Physical jobs.

34:41Yes.

34:42Physical jobs with smart automation.

34:44Right.

34:45Right. So if you are able to architect systems like that, manufacturing can scale much faster.

34:53Okay.

34:53And that is happening in the world right now. Right. I know friends who are running robotics and automation companies who have grown to 3x capacity without adding a single additional capital, right, because they have made their systems more efficient. And they need smart people to come and do this, right? So manufacturing is going to become the differentiator again, right? It used to be during my dad's time that manufacturing was the big deal. During our time, it was all about services and, you know, technology. Now technology-led manufacturing is going to be a big deal. It is going to be something that will hopefully take this country and generally the world to a new level of efficiency, productivity and creation as well. Right? There are so many new things that can be developed. Yeah, so I have two, not three. Okay. Fair enough.

35:50So before we move ahead, Ganesh, I would like to tell the audience over here. So Ganesh, startup Momoe was one of the pioneers when it came to payments, right? They powered NICE Road toll for the first time ever in the history of country, right? A toll taking digital payments.

36:09Yeah, this happened in Bangalore. Was this possible because it was Bangalore and tech adoption was easy over there?

36:15And how, or rather let me put it this way, how difficult was it to convince a tollgate operator to get on a digital payment mechanism?

36:25Oh, big story in itself. We actually spent almost a year, eight months, trying to convince them to accept digital payments. Surprisingly, they were interested in hearing us out. That is the first step, right? A lot of people are not even interested in talking, right?

36:45Right. They were interested in talking and hearing what our solution was. That itself was a big step. I think there's a little bit of Bangalore there. Openness to experiment with technology is something that, and most of their commuters were techies, right? Every day somebody who was using the NICE Road toll was a techie who was going to his office and back, right? So hence that was something that they were open to in terms of conversation. But still it took that 8 months for us to actually arrive at a solution that worked for them and us, right? One big thing there was, they wanted something that was completely hardware free. FASTag involves RFID, right? So there is an RFID reader that you need to install. There is an RFID tag that needs to be on the car.

37:36Correct.

37:37Or the vehicle, whichever you have, and that interface always has maintenance issues. So many times those, you know, readers will not work.

37:47Then they will have a mobile scanner. There is another piece of hardware that they have to carry. Right? There are so many things that can go wrong with hardware. And when you're in a toll, that's fundamentally a, you know, operations problem, right?

38:00Every time it gets stuck, it's a huge problem for them from a consumer satisfaction and revenue as well, right? The lesser the number of vehicles going through because of the time taken, the lesser their revenue is at the end of the day. It was a direct hit on their revenue. So they did not want anything hardware, and that worked in our favor because we were pure digital solution. We did not have any hardware requirement at. They already had internet cables that they had installed for each of their toll booths. So they had internet connection. Connectivity was critical. But beyond that, it was completely digital, right? So you could just, your mobile, you could enter your vehicle number and load money into the wallet. That was the RBL wallet, by the way. You could load money into your wallet on Momoe. At the toll, they are supposed to read your vehicle number, right? So they will read the vehicle number automatically. There's a server call that goes and fetches your account balance.

38:58If the toll amount is there, it will deduct that toll amount and you can just drive through. That was the solution that we made completely digital. No hardware required other than the person's phone, which they will have anyways. Right.

39:09But this was a differentiator altogether. Yeah.

39:12Compared to any other available solutions back then.

39:15Then what went wrong after that? You were pioneers in payment solutions. You started simplifying all the complex solutions. Might be payment at a restaurant, standing in a queue at a place like at a supermarket, or might be even the toll gate.

39:33Yeah.

39:34Then why did you plan to take acquisition offer? Why did you become someone like a Paytm?

39:42So let me go back to how the business model was built, right? Momoe was offline payments. We were only doing restaurants, retail stores and toll roads, right? Because of that, the entire business was built around offline acquisition. So my sales team used to be like a FMCG beat sales team, onboarding on grounding. They would go, they would talk to restaurants. I mean, you've done this at restaurants. So you know, people have to go down on the ground. They will note down, okay, there are 100 shops here which can potentially shops and restaurants that can accept digital payments, and then they will go one by one and they will acquire them, right? This is how you all did it.

40:27This was, it was a completely offline acquisition. Yeah.

40:30Okay.

40:31Right.

40:31That's how it was done back.

40:32And that's how Zomato built as well, by the way. They used to go to every restaurant and get them on board. Even now they do that.

40:38Right.

40:39Correct.

40:39So it's an offline, it at the face of it, it looks like a digital business, but it is actually an offline business. Yes.

40:46Right. Once you've done acquisition of the restaurants, then you need to acquire customers. So we used to go pin code by pin code. In this pin code, I need to acquire X number of restaurants and retail stores. On this road, I had to acquire at least X number of restaurants. Once I acquired those is when I will start doing hyperlocal marketing. Then, think about it, right? If you're downloading BookMyShow, as soon as you download BookMyShow, you can actually book a ticket sitting where you are.

41:14Correct.

41:14At home.

41:15Correct.

41:15But if you download Momoe, you can't do anything with it until you walk into a restaurant where Momoe is accepted.

41:22Right.

41:23Right. True.

41:24So we used to get a lot of one-star reviews saying, download, I don't know what to do with this, because Paytm and MobiKwik and Freecharge were all doing recharges at that time, right? So mobile payments meant recharge.

41:37Correct.

41:38Right.

41:38During when we came in, it was very new, right, offline payments. So for me, acquiring a customer at the point where they are making the payment was more critical. So my entire marketing was offline.

41:50I used to do marketing at the store. I used to have, you know, standies that are stand there. There used to be billfold stickers that said pay with Momoe. The waiters used to be wearing t-shirts that says ask me about digital payments.

42:03Oh right. So that's how we did marketing. It was all on the ground because it is offline. I cannot go pan India day one, right? You have to do it pin code by pin code. It is a hyperlocal business. This is how Uber is built. This is how Ola is built. These are hyperlocal businesses. Correct.

42:20You need to build merchant concentration and then you need to build customer concentration.

42:26And because of this, we could not go pan India. We could not expand as fast. Right? So we had to go city by city. We had to go pin code by pin code. Whereas Paytm, because of their business model, which was recharge, recharge could be done across India on day one, right, as long as you were on one of the telecom operators, which you were, if you had a phone, you could recharge on Paytm, right? Hence the business model was built on digital acquisition and digital transactions.

42:56They could expand pan India on day one, and when they got their Alibaba round funding around, suddenly because Alipay had done this offline as well. They announced their intention to come online, come offline, and start powering payments in the real world as well.

43:16Now how, with a company that has raised 1.2 million funding, how do you compete with somebody who has raised 600, 600 million, right? How do you compete? How do you scale? The big question was, how do we scale? How do we go pan India as soon as possible? This was the question. Incidentally, there were ways to go. Either you could acquire merchants pan India and then start getting customers, or you could acquire customers pan India and start getting merchants, or you could have somebody who has both the merchant base as well as the consumer base and you power the technology to go.

43:52Okay.

43:53Right. We had built a technology that would work on 2.5G because it was mobile payments. Right?

44:00So while everybody else was struggling with 30% conversion on mobile, if you are paying using mobile, people were struggling with 30% conversion at that time because of the data problem. We had built technology that was 65%, 70% conversion, right? Which was huge, right? Myntra had just launched their app only business and it failed miserably because people could not pay on their phone.

44:23Oh, their payment stack was not great. They had to revert back to, you know, web plus mobile. That was a huge experiment that they did, but it failed because payment was not possible on mobile. We had built that tech stack and that was a USP that we had.

44:38From that perspective we wanted to go scale, and here was a player. So I bank, by the way, at that time had the maximum number of merchants because of their cost business, the swipe machine, they had one lakh merchants, 1.2 lakh merchants I remember, right, that was the number that I had. They were the largest in terms of cost.

44:57Okay.

44:57Provider, and they had that much scale.

45:01Everybody's familiar with Meesho, right?

45:03Yeah.

45:03Everybody knows Meesho. Yeah.

45:05ShopClues was the Meesho model, right?

45:07They had micro entrepreneurs. They had micro retailers. People who have a shop, who have a boutique, right? A tailor shop who wants to come online.

45:18They had those kind of retailers on their platform. And they had one and a half lakh merchants already. They were bigger than ICA Bank in terms of the number of merchants who wanted to digitize their catalog.

45:29And these were all offline merchants.

45:30These are mostly offline merchants. Yes. As opposed to like a Flipkart who had distributors and stockists and brands directly on the platform. ShopClues had merchants.

45:41They had retailers who were on the platform, right? They were the ones who had the, you know, dukan in the neighborhood who wanted to sell online as well. That was the group of people that they had. Now that is the merchant that we wanted.

45:54You want it, right.

45:55Exactly.

45:56And hence we said, hey, we will give the technology, let us partner together and go to the market with this. Now I have pan India scale. They already have 1.5 lakh merchants. And in the two years that I was there we grew that, I was leading the merchant ecosystem.

46:09Right. So we grew that from one and a half lakh merchants to almost five and a half lakh merchants.

46:13Right. So that was the scale of merchant base that we built out there, and Momoe was literally, you know, along with accepting digital payments, it was also a way for the merchant to digitize their catalog. So they could just take a picture of their product. We had built product image matching algorithms which could find the best image that matches the product, and they could build a digital catalog just by the click of their phone. Right? So that's the way we had built that entire automation stack, right? So then Momoe became the merchant boss, digital boss, right? So that's how we built that out. So that was the reason for the acquisition.

46:53So this comes to this question. How obsessed were you with being first? Because in the payment space, right? We saw that Paytm came, it came with a big funding, it capitalized the market, it spread the wave of adoption for digital payments. And after that BharatPe came into the picture much later and it could still make its own market share. So should founders be obsessed with this market first or maybe idea first initiative in their mind, or should they wait for somebody to try that idea and then maybe go into the market? Depends on the industry. If you are in tech, okay, and there is a high potential play in tech, then you should be earlier the better. Okay, because in tech, the end game, look at it from an endgame perspective, right? Who are the top e-commerce players, anyone in India, nobody's talking. Okay, top ecom players in India?

47:59Flipkart, Amazon, Meesho, maybe Meesho, number three, right?

48:05Is not Myntra, is not the is part of Flipkart. Okay. And Nika is the other one, right?

48:11Who are the top, I don't know, restaurant delivery players?

48:17Swiggy.

48:18Yeah, correct.

48:18You're done, right?

48:20Who are the top mobile payment players?

48:24Paytm.

48:24Paytm, Google Pay, PhonePe.

48:26Correct.

48:27Amazon Pay to some extent.

48:28Navi.

48:28Navi is coming up now.

48:29You just raised money.

48:31Yeah. Yeah. Navi is coming up now. Correct. But it's an oligopoly that you end up in. True. It is typically the top two or three players who will remain and everybody else will fall away or get acquired.

48:41Right? So typically that is the end game.

48:43If you have to be somebody who survives at the end game, you have to build your scale as fast as possible. Which is why tech businesses raise money to build market share as fast as possible.

48:55Correct?

48:55The earlier you are in the ecosystem, the faster you can build this. That is a hypothesis.

49:00At least that is a thought process, and hence being earlier in the game matters.

49:04True. But if you're building a brand, like a consumer brand of a product, there are a million ways you can actually sustain in the market. You may not become the multi-billion dollar outcome that a tech company will give, but you can be a hundred million to a billion dollar business anywhere in that space quite easily, right?

49:23Not easily. Sorry, I'm oversimplifying it, but I'm saying multiple of those kind of brands can exist.

49:30Like think about the chocolate market. No, right? Which is the chocolate for hunger?

49:38Snickers.

49:39Yeah.

49:39Oh, yeah.

49:40Which is the chocolate for gifting?

49:42Cadbury.

49:42Ferrero.

49:43Ferrero.

49:44Cadbury for celebration.

49:46Correct.

49:46Right. Which is a chocolate for, I don't know, taking a break.

49:51Kit Kat.

49:52Kit Kat.

49:52Correct.

49:53All of these are chocolates. It's the same thing.

49:55Oh, okay.

49:56But yet they are positioned differently in the market. They appeal to different emotions with the customer and value propositions and use cases with the customer, and hence all of them can coexist in the market. So if you're building a brand, finding that niche is more important and communicating that well is more important.

50:15If you're in tech, it's a very different game. You get what I'm saying?

50:17Yeah, I understand, Ganesh, what you rightly said. You were there at the right time at the right place. Paytm was there, which was at a much larger scale than you, but what you rightly said, there is still space wherein there could be two or three players in that particular domain, right? Apart from Paytm, there was only MobiKwik. Weren't there investors pushing you to raise a better round or larger round and go and compete with these guys?

50:48Yes, there was, obviously there was pressure. We actually went out to raise in the market, right? So we went and spoke to Tiger Global, and Kalyan was the guy who's leading Flipkart now. He basically said, look, this is an interesting proposition, you have a USP in terms of technology, if you want scale, I have five different e-commerce businesses, right? So they were investors in Flipkart, they were investors in Myntra, they were investors in ShopClues, they were investors in Delhivery, which was a delivery logistics partner who also wanted cash on delivery payments digital, right?

51:27They were invested in Ola, they had investors and they had investment in Quikr as well, right? So all these are digital e-commerce platforms, and all of them wanted payment solutions. So he said, look, this is an interesting proposition, pure consumer play, there is a Maharati sitting there with $600 million of funding, you may not be able to raise more than 20 million right now, but if you're able to use that technology, I'm willing to come in, right? Then we went and spoke to all the portfolio companies of his, and here's what came out. Every one of them had just raised funding, right? For them, the technology Y stack was a build or buy decision. What do I mean by that? Build or buy? Do people understand? Either they can build it themselves in house.

52:16Correct.

52:16Or they can go and acquire a company to get that technology. True.

52:19It was a build or buy decision for them.

52:21Speed meant buy was a better option, right? If you have to get faster to the market. It was a simple build or buy decision for them. All of them said, come join us and let us build this together.

52:34Mhm.

52:34Right. Nobody said, I will take your technology and I will use it and others can use it as well, because all of them wanted differentiation, right? All of them wanted to be the bigger player in the market.

52:50Differentiation was critical and mobile payments was a big differentiator, and all of them said, come, I will acquire you and I will use this technology.

52:59Okay.

53:00Right. So all those conversations that we went for funding became acquisition conversations. Okay, for us we had to solve for scale, right?

53:08At some point in time, the decision became, hey, you know what? Either we die or we get acquired and build scale within that platform, right?

53:16And that was how the acquisition happened. Right? So the intent was to go and raise money. It just so happened that those conversations became acquisition, eventually moved towards acquisition.

53:25Correct.

53:25Okay.

53:27Big, another big macro trend that happened there. UPI gives you 0% MDR, right? We had initially the credit card digital payment, on credit card you have a 2 to 3% MDR. Correct. MDR is a merchant discount rate, that is the amount of money you get per transaction, right?

53:44That became zero as soon as UPI launched.

53:46Right. The other thing that happened was payment banks launched, right?

53:50Raghuram Rajan had this experiment of launching payment banks. Airtel came into the market, came into the market, came into the market that time it was Reliance, but they came into the market. Mahindra, Tech Mahindra came into the market. All these are massive, massive companies with huge customer bases. How do we compete against that? Right? So competition, suddenly the macro scenario changed and the business model, core business model of your, you know, revenue became zero.

54:19True.

54:19So there are so many other factors that were happening around us.

54:22Right? Hence it was the game was either you keep raising funds, which is what happened with Paytm, or, you know, Google Pay, which basically, you know, even now bleeds money, right, right, to get to that scale, or you go and work with somebody who already has a business model and you are one part of that business model where they can afford to spend that money, right?

54:46So what you're trying to say is become an enabler.

54:49We became an enabler, yes.

54:50Correct. So is that the trend right now? Because I've been seeing this in a lot of startups today also, that they are preferring to becoming an enabler rather than a differentiator in a crowded market. There will be many more enablers as businesses that will come up, because think about it, right, if you are launching an e-commerce brand, you will need to go do marketing.

55:15Meta and Google are out there who are enablers for you.

55:20You will need to go out and source a product.

55:23A network who is a supply chain sourcing company will help you there.

55:28You need to accept payments, there is Razorpay and, you know. Right?

55:33All these payment gateways, Cashfree and all that, guys who are out there in the market who are enablers. You will need to do customer relationship management or retention marketing. For that there are people like Quick Engage, MoEngage, CleverTap who are out there in the market who are enablers. You need to build an e-commerce store.

55:51Shopify is an enabler. WooCommerce is an enabler.

55:54Right?

55:55For every industry there are multiple enablers who are there. These are called picks and shovels businesses. Right? So when the great California rush happened, gold rush happened, the people who sold picks and shovels, correct? They made the most of money.

56:09Were the ones who made the money, right?

56:11Forget about the people who were looking for gold, they may or may not have made money.

56:15Very few of them got lucky, but the shovels business made money.

56:18True.

56:19So there is nothing wrong with enabler businesses, right? You can build enabler businesses. As long as the industry is growing, you will grow with that industry as an enabler, right? Either you become a part of the core industry and build, or you build an enabler that helps, right. Enabler businesses are more sustainable by design because you will get paid regardless of whether that business True.

56:42is working very well or not. They will have to pay you. They have no other option, right? And hence enabler businesses exist.

56:49And yeah, it's a more sustainable way to build a business.

56:53Cool. So way back in 2012, Ganesh, you raised one of the largest seed rounds of $1.2 million. Can you tell us more about that journey? Like was it that you had your network with these angels, or you pitched them through some programs, or might be some networks? How did this happen?

57:12I'm so sorry to interrupt. Can you give us a strategy of, let's say, if I'm building a startup today, how would I go around approaching people like you and Koustubh?

57:22Sure. I'll tell you about Bangalore. Every startup investor in Bangalore is sitting in, at that time we're sitting in this place called Koramangala and Indiranagar.

57:37Correct.

57:37Right now there is another place called HSR which has come up, right?

57:41That is where the investors are. If you have to catch the eyes of investors, you need to be present there.

57:47You need to find the way to get to them. Right. Okay. Yes, we had some introductions through our friends, batchmates, whatever, colleagues, ex-colleagues who knew people who knew people. Eventually, we got some introductions. But the meat of it was at Koramangala.

58:09When we started our digital payments Momoe business, the first 20 restaurants we signed up were in Koramangala and Indiranagar. And this was a very calculated move because we knew that all the investors are sitting here.

58:20Okay.

58:20And all the techies are sitting here, by the way. True.

58:22The people who will actually try it out as an early adopter is also sitting there. That's my customer.

58:27My core customer is sitting there. Early adopter is sitting there. Right.

58:32So that area became our hub to begin with. And incidentally, the investors who first saw this potential were people who walked into a cafe which had Momoe. They're like, "Huh, what is this Momoe?" There's a bright yellow signage. The color was also very attractive. They're like, "What is this?" Curiosity. They download the app. Suddenly they see their bill on their phone. Magic, right? They're blown away.

58:55Correct.

58:56They are able to pay using their credit cards on the phone and they are able to walk out. Right?

59:01They did this organically. We did not ask them.

59:03Okay.

59:04There were people who discovered us and found this and then reached out to us and said, "Oh, this is very interesting." And then our first conversation with a partner or a vice president or whoever in the VC fund, we used to call them to the restaurant. We used to sit down with them. We used to get them to download the app and experience it as we were pitching.

59:26So, it was an experiential pitch.

59:28I didn't have to, you know, show a presentation, right?

59:31I just had to tell them to download the app and experience it for themselves.

59:35And that magic happened. You could see their eyes open, right? Oh my god, I just saw my bill, right? And that was the moment that things shifted. They saw the potential of what could happen with this, right? And that's how the investment happened, right? So number one, if you're raising funds, find warm introductions to VCs and have a very powerful problem you can solve. If they are able to experience it, nothing like it, right?

1:00:01If you are able to find a way to experience, get them to experience it, nothing like it. And by the way, there was another big advantage of that. We never had to pay for the bill. It was on their phone. So they always paid, right? So yeah. So my first, our first investment was from these people. And by the way, our first investor was this company called Chirate. Now it used to be called a very different name at that time. But when they came in, right, after the investment happened, our first meeting with the investors, you know what, we have evaluated at least 15 ideas in exactly the same space that you've talked about.

1:00:42Okay. And all these ideas have come from people who have been in the financial services industry. They have been ex-bankers. They have been ex, I don't know, insurance providers. They have been, you know, payments folks. We have evaluated 15 different ideas and we have rejected them. We came in and we funded you because of one reason and that reason is you have no idea what you're doing.

1:01:05Oh.

1:01:06You are coming in from a completely different perspective of customer experience.

1:01:10Correct. Everybody else understands how complex the payment ecosystem is.

1:01:15Correct?

1:01:16So all their pitches to us were, we will take two years to build the tech, one year to build it, the second year to get all the licenses, right, and the certifications and the data security aspects set up.

1:01:32Two years later we will launch.

1:01:34True.

1:01:36You are the only guys who came and said, boss, it is working right now.

1:01:39Right. And we had no idea, by the way. The product that we had built was literally taking the PayU payment gateway, putting it on the phone, and building a location, you know, restaurant finder, right, where you could go and pay, and the integration with the POS, which was a non-trivial thing, but we did that, right? We had no idea how complex the payment ecosystem is because we didn't build the payment ecosystem. It was PayU's payment gateway that we used to begin with, right? But we put together a solution that could solve the customer experience problem.

1:02:14That's why they invested in us, and the first thing they told us in that first meeting was, please get a CTO who understands payments, otherwise this company is going to die very soon.

1:02:25Okay, true.

1:02:26You are building the customer experience layer, but you have no idea what's coming.

1:02:31Correct.

1:02:31Right. Somebody will come and crack down and say this solution is not regulatory allowed, and they're going to crack down very soon. So you have to build robust technology stacks. So we built that stack along the way as we scaled, right? But that was the reason that they invested in us, because we were not from the industry. Very contrarian bet, but the reason is because we didn't have the emotional baggage or the experience baggage of what building a payment tech entails, and hence we could come up with a very fresh approach of doing things. Correct.

1:03:03So Ganesh, now let's move, we discussed a lot about Momoe. I think let's move towards Flatheads. Flatheads, I think you started after moving out of ShopClues. Flatheads, if you see the pricing, that's my understanding, I'm talking about Flatheads in India, were priced in a range, if I consider price parity index, at the same price wherein On is priced in the US, sort of, yeah.

1:03:29Sort of, yeah. Journey also, when On started versus flat started, timeline wise you were on the same time frame, but what On has become today versus what journey you went through, Flatheads is not quite similar. What do you think, if given a chance again, what could be those three things that you could correct with Flatheads so that you could reach, you could have reached something like On success at this point of time? Interesting question. So Flatheads were shoes for work wear, right? The great comfortable shoes that you could wear for 14 hours or more every day at your workplace and beyond. Right? So that was the core proposition.

1:04:16Right? We launched in November 2019 and COVID happened in March 2020. Right?

1:04:25Since within 4 months of launching a brand, right? Ever since that happened, it was always a survival game. We were literally fighting for survival because nobody was going to the office, nobody was wearing shoes, right? And we were in a market which did not exist at that time, right? First wave hit, sales went to zero, opened up, we picked up again, second wave hit, sales went to zero again. It's a non-essential good. So you cannot sell during COVID, you can't deliver during COVID, right?

1:05:01So typically if you're building something, you need to hit escape velocity quickly, right?

1:05:10Right. And that escape velocity for a brand typically is in the Cr, two Cr a month run rate. Every time we hit 50 lakhs we went to zero again, so we had to start from scratch again. Okay, at that point your business economics don't make sense. You spend a lot more than you earn. Once you hit that 1 Cr plus a month run rate is when you start seeing goodness happening in business economics. Your overhead costs, your, you know, people cost, your engineering costs, all that starts getting accounted for in the revenue and the profits that you bring in.

1:05:51Correct.

1:05:51And marketing starts moving as well. That flywheel starts moving. We were never able to hit that live. Thinking back, one of my investors, I remember when the first lockdown hit, I asked one of my investors who was also a mentor, what should I do, right? The business does not exist anymore. What should I do? He said, look, you've already raised the money. The business does not exist right now.

1:06:17This thing, COVID, is a black swan event. This will happen once in a generation. It has happened to you. Take a two years holiday.

1:06:28Okay, put the money in the bank. Do something else. Take a 2-year holiday. Come back two years later because the market will still exist. The problem that you are solving still exists. Come back two years later, the market will be there. Then you can start building.

1:06:46I did not listen to him because I'm, That's really a wise solution.

1:06:50It is. I mean, looking back, you know, hindsight is 2020, looking back it made so much sense, right? Market opened up after 2022, two years later.

1:07:02But when you're an entrepreneur in the battlefield, you don't see that, right?

1:07:08We continued to try to survive and try to sell shoes when people were not buying shoes.

1:07:15That is probably the biggest thing that went wrong. If I had to go back and do it, I would have done it very differently.

1:07:22Okay.

1:07:23I would have taken that 2-year holiday.

1:07:26Right.

1:07:26I remember a friend of mine who started a last mile connectivity business. So he used to have cabs from the metro station to your home or metro station to office.

1:07:39Okay.

1:07:39Right. He had raised money from Stellaris.

1:07:43The day COVID happened, within a week he made a decision. He told Stellaris, take the money back. Okay.

1:07:51He closed the business and he went on to do something else.

1:07:55Oh, okay.

1:07:56He took that call because he knew that, boss, nobody's traveling. This is not going to happen. He decided that he's going to, you know, give back the money to the investors. Now, he built a lot of goodwill because of that. He did a lot of other, you know, things since, but that was a great business call in hindsight, right? Yeah, we could not take that call. Was that one of the biggest mistakes then?

1:08:20I don't know if I'd call it a mistake.

1:08:23We did try different things, right? We launched sliders, chapels which you could wear at home.

1:08:29We launched the, you know, 10,000 step shoe which was a lot more comfortable, like at leisure was exploding at that time.

1:08:36People were buying joggers and, you know, comfortable at leisure wear.

1:08:42We built those kind of shoes which was a 10,000 step shoe. But it was too, how do I say, constrained because there was not enough, because our capital was already locked in the first set of shoes that we had built, right?

1:08:56And you are not able to release that capital, so we were always capital constraint to build something in a big way, right? So You want to share that story, how your first consignment was stuck for one and a half years? I think everybody would like to hear about it.

1:09:09Yeah. So the first set of shoes, we had placed an order for 10,000 shoes, right? First 5,000 came and we launched. The second 5,000 was supposed to come, you know, 3 months later, COVID hit. Anyway, supply chain was disrupted and then the China Doklam standoff happened with India. Everything in customs was stuck.

1:09:38Okay.

1:09:39Right. So our shipment of the second set of shoes was stuck there. It was 5,000 plus 5,000, the next slot as well we had ordered, it was stuck there, right? We could not release it and it was stuck there for a year, by the way. We got it in 2021, right? What do you do when your inventory, you've already paid, right, inventory is stuck, you cannot sell, right? Massive issue. And no more, if one is stuck, the next set of shoes will never come, so you can't work with the suppliers anymore. So I don't have the next set of shoes to sell.

1:10:15What do I do? Right? So this is what we did. We split our team, right? All the Indian suppliers that we had contacted earlier at the idea stage, who had basically said, no, we are not going to work with you because this is too much innovation and R&D which we don't want to take up because we have enough, you know, orders already. We have enough people to occupy our capacity and this is too unbuilt and a new idea which we didn't want to invest in.

1:10:50Their orders from Europe got cancelled.

1:10:52They were exporting shoes. Their orders got cancelled. So they had spare capacity. So during the pandemic, during the first wave, me and the materials expert, we were in Tirupur, building in the workshop, in the production floor, prototyping and building bamboo fiber fabric with which we launched the sliders eventually. Right. Correct.

1:11:17So bamboo fibers, how do we do the knit, because Tirupur is famous for knitting, right, fabrics. So we were calibrating their machines. We were buying needles that can fit that bamboo fiber. All those innovations we were doing in the factory. Everybody else was at home. I was sitting in the factory and we were living there in Tirupur, sitting in the factory and doing this, and very scary time. Huh? When you know, COVID, you're sitting in with a bunch of factory workers.

1:11:46Factory workers. Correct.

1:11:47But yeah, that's the life we live. My co-founder was in Ludhiana. He was sourcing soles.

1:11:52Correct. For the shoe and building the supply chain for assembly of the shoes, right? So, building those lasts and everything. So, when the first wave opened up, we had an India supply chain which did not exist. We started with China as a supply chain. We built a complete India supply chain which actually helped us go to market much faster later, right? We could just, you know, Tirupur is a drive away from Bangalore. You could literally go to the factory, sit there, make the next set of prototypes and launch within 3 months, which was never possible in China. It was minimum of 8 to 9 months of product development work that had to happen.

1:12:29Perfect. I think, guys, we are running out of time. One last set of question. We need one-liners from you.

1:12:36Okay.

1:12:36I would like to give you a hint, or might be I'd like to give you a word on which we need one-line answer from you.

1:12:43Okay.

1:12:43Starting with Momoe. Momoe. Game-changing idea. I think a little ahead of its time. Bad timing.

1:12:57Yeah, it could have become the Uniqlo of footwear in India. Accelerators for your business once you have product market fit, but tough cookies when you have to deal with, you know, tough business effectively, you're an employee of a VC once you raise your funds, right?

1:13:22Shark Tank.

1:13:23Again, something that has changed India's perception of entrepreneurship like nobody else can do. It has become a dinner table conversation where, you know, everybody is talking about what entrepreneurship is. My 10-year-old daughter is talking about how whether they gave the right amount of equity for the amount of money they raised. This is unimaginable. Entrepreneurship has become acceptable in everyday life because of Shark Tank. So hats off to sort of final thing.

1:13:53Yeah. So I think I'd like to ask the two of you this question. Who is your favorite shark, and who is your favorite shark? Because I think y'all two are entrepreneurs out here on the stage. So I think it's a tough question to answer, but I have personally met Anupam multiple times. The way he thinks, the way he structures his thoughts, and I think the way he envisions about the future, I think for that perspective I personally like Anupam. What about you?

1:14:21Nice. I think respect to everybody who have built their own businesses, they are all entrepreneurship, you know, giants in their own right. I like Peyush for the level of thinking that he has, you know, put in to build Lenskart to where it is right now. It is an industry disruptor. It is, you know, a vertical, vertical business. So they manufacture their own products, but whereas most other brands actually source lenses and frames, they manufacture their own. So it's a vertically integrated business end to end that he has built. Unbelievable. Puff it.