Anurag Jain
on Milkbasket
Co-founder and Ex-COO of Milkbasket(Acq. by Reliance Retail)
- Episode
- 01
- Released
- Length
- 89 min
- Recorded live at
- SCMHRD, Pune
The story
Anurag Jain is a co-founder of Milkbasket and its former COO, the person in charge of daily operations. He was a major in the Indian Army. Later he worked for nine years in companies, including Samsung Electronics. In 2015, at about 36, he and three co-founders started Milkbasket. People ordered milk and groceries on the app until midnight. The order reached their door before 7 a.m.
For about 18 months, the team served only three housing societies in Gurgaon, to prove the idea worked. About 10 months in, the founders had no cash left, but they kept going. Some early investment came from their own customers. Milkbasket later grew to more than 400 societies in Delhi NCR, Hyderabad and Bangalore. Its app served 1.3 million households. During COVID-19, its revenue doubled. But investors lost interest in businesses like this. Even as a market leader, Milkbasket could not raise new money, and it ran short of cash.
Amazon, BigBasket and Swiggy all showed interest. In the end, Reliance Retail bought 96.5% of Milkbasket. Anurag cannot say it was the best deal. But at that time, it was best for the company and its employees. Investors got their money back. It also covers the first deliveries, his work at Zepto and student questions.
Key lessons
Know your customer and check that their problem is real before you build technology. Milkbasket started taking orders with pen and paper, not a finished app.
Watch at 26:13A promise of money is not money. Count an investment as real only when the money reaches your bank account.
Watch at 33:58Focus on making a good product, not on chasing investors. If customers love the product, investors will come to you.
Watch at 44:57A startup needs many things to go right, and timing is one of them. During COVID-19, Milkbasket's revenue doubled, but investors lost interest and it could not raise new money.
Watch at 55:10Think about profit early. Anurag says not having products under Milkbasket's own brand was a missed chance, as they earn more profit.
Watch at 1:09:45
In Anurag's words
Believe me when I say this, that any commitment is a commitment only if the money lands in your bank account.
Even after being the market leaders, we were not able to raise the next round of funding, and that's why the cash crunches and other things started to happen.
In hindsight, I cannot say that was the best deal that happened, but at that point of time it was best for the company and for the interest of the employees.
Full transcript
Made from YouTube's automatic captions and lightly edited. Speaker names are not marked, and there may be small errors.
Show transcriptHide transcript
0:00Anan's wife, she was pregnant and she was also doing the marketing for us in those initial days. 2 years, 300 crores raised and spent, moving from 1,000 orders per day to around 1 lakh orders per day. How did you plan these things? When you have conviction, when you believe in something, that reflects on how you are speaking to someone, the way you speak and the way you are convinced about your product. I think 50% battle is won over there itself. And in the 6 years of my journey with Milkbasket, it was just one day when the covid hit we were not able to deliver. Otherwise, all the rest of the days we had delivered, whether it was floods in kura or anything. It's only the conviction of the founder that customers are looking at leaving Milkbasket for about 2, 3 years. I used to still getting calls that Milkbasket, and the team were privileged enough to source one of their first funding rounds by their customers. You should be chasing your product, and if the product is good and if the product is making the customers fall in love with the product, then the investors will start chasing you. You know, don't go to your parents to ask so much about with covid. I think the investor sentiments had also gone down. Even after being the market leaders, we were not able to raise the next round of funding. That's why the cash crunches and other things started to happen. So thank you for joining us on this first of its podcast, What Went Wrong, in association with SCMHRD. So Anurag sir, Indian parents usually, when you look at their happiness quotient, it is at its peak when a kid gets a government job, then mediocre when you land up in a private role, and the lowest when you tell them that you want to start something. And you did everything. You took up a government job, then left it to take up a private job, then told your parents that you are not starting up, you are going to deliver milk.
2:04What were you trying to do with them? Was it right or wrong?
2:07Hi everyone, and thank you for calling me here. I hope I'm audible till the back.
2:13So I'm glad Koustubh wants to start with a bouncer. So yeah, I think every parent will always want the best for their kids, and you know, a stable job, a government job or doing a 5 figure job in a private company definitely sort of check boxes the list. But I definitely had a different trajectory, starting from a government. So I won't say Indian Army is a government job, but yeah, it is a government organization that you serve. So serving the nation was definitely a key aspect, and it taught me a lot of things, made me a leader. And postrad, doing a course from Axel and then going for a 9 year stint with the corporate, it again was a learning lesson for me. But when I decided to jump into the startup world, I don't think that even I was prepared. It just happened. So but it was at the onset that okay, you are starting with some sort of a belief and you want to do something big, and that's where the journey started. So yeah, definitely the parents were not so delighted, nor was the family, but we had some sort of a conviction that we will make it through.
3:31Perfect. So a very simple thing. How much savings did you have in your account while you started this Milkbasket journey? Because I think I would want to know the number, that say if I want to do my startup tomorrow, what would be that approximate number?
3:48See, Jinay, I think there is no amount of saving can actually prepare you to jump into a startup, because once you are into a startup, you are actually not earning anything. There's no monthly income which is happening and you are all depending upon something that it is going to work. So you're investing your time, energy, effort and your opportunity cost into it. So I definitely didn't had you know a lot of savings at that point of time, but yeah, few lakhs. But definitely I had that conviction that if it doesn't work, then I still have in it me, in myself, to be able to go back to any job. So at least I had that confidence in myself. So that's how I took that leap of faith.
4:38So let's start from the beginning of the journey, Anurag. Yeah.
4:41When you started Milkbasket, there was I think Peppertap in the market, which was delivering groceries in around 2, 2 and a half hours, 3 hours dives, and the market moved from 2 hours delivery to just 10 minutes delivery in 5 to 6 years. So I think 2015 to 21 is when Blinkit and the Zepto of the world came in. Now when in 2015 you started Milkbasket, when you knew that this period was going to just shorten down, what was the reason that you chose milk delivery, and that too in a traditional milk run style? Because that's going against the market, right, not with the market. What made you think that would work in future? So there are multiple reasons to it, and one of the main reasons was that when back in 2015, if you guys remember, there were the likes of Peppertap and gers, and they were all doing hyper local grocery delivery. And by hyper local grocery delivery, the business model is basically such that you are actually having some shoppers who are placed at certain shops to shop on behalf of the customers and then deliver it in 2 hours. So they were able to raise money from VCs and you know they were growing on the VC money, but we didn't wanted to do that sort of a business, and the main reason was that there was no control there. The fundamentals were quite wrong.
5:59So when you don't have any control on the inventory, when the customer has ordered for 10 items and you are only able to deliver six items, when you don't know the expiry date of those items, when the supply chain is totally broken, so all those things were not making them very sustainable. So that's where we sort of iterated for about 3 months, and being a corporate employee also, we also learned from our experience that like say yesterday I came from Gura to Pune. Now if I'm going back from Pune to Gura and reaching Guramo at say 10 p.m. the night, if my family says that I need milk and bread in the morning, there is not going to be any grocery shop open at that point of time to get those things. That is where the idea came to open the shop till 12:00 midnight, and whatever you order till 12:00 will be delivered to you before 7:00 a.m.
6:54practically before you even wake up, and that's the time when you know you have your kids going to the schools, where you are preparing for the offices and all. But if you think about it, the idea was so simple that whatever I'm ordering, I can order on the go, and whatever I need, I'm going to need it early in the morning to make the breakfast or to make the lunch for the husband or something like that. So there was no urgency. It was a planned behavior that we were trying to incorporate, and we just wanted to sort of replicate the neighborhood Kirana store and make it online.
7:31But do you still think that this need exists, especially when I know that I can order anything from 6:00 in the morning to 3:00 at midnight and that will get delivered in 10 minutes to me?
7:42Yes. So I think Milkbasket made people lazier, and now with the advent of 10 minutes delivery, people have stopped planning as well.
7:51Okay.
7:52Okay.
7:53But I still don't get it. We had two dwalas for the last, so we've had them for the last 100 years now.
7:59Yeah.
8:00So how exactly just the milk part solves the problem for the customer? Because see, every pala comes in the morning today between 5 to 8:00 a.m., right? So what was that one thing that Milkbasket was doing that was different from these guys? I think in your question only you have given me the answer, because every dudala is a localized small entrepreneur who is setting up his shop in some city, some society, and he, because of being at a small level, he is supply chain is little bit unpredictable, because he is dependent on few people. And that's where he is going to supply you the milk between 7 to 8, or 7 sorry 5 to 8 or 5 to 10:00 a.m. in the morning. So if you are going to send your kids to school at 7:00 a.m.
8:51in the morning and if the milk is coming at 8:00 a.m. in the morning, then there's no fun in having that. So that gap was existing already in the society. All we did was that we brought it online and we made it much more standardized. So the experience was managed, because our only promise to our first 25 customer was that you give us 500 rupees today, recharge your wallet, and tomorrow morning you will have milk at your doorstep before 7:00 a.m. So Anurag, in retail business, milk is not considered to be a profitable product as such. It's just, I would say, entry point for your customer, because milk, egg and breads, these things customer will come in and he'll end up spending for some other producers, buying some other produce.
9:43Yeah. Now when you knew that milk was not going to generate revenues, whereas in daily consumptions there could have been other products like vegetables, fruits and vegetables, which would have given you healthier margins, what was the decision of picking up milk as your first product, which had only 3 to 4% margins versus something like a fresh fruits and vegetables which could have given you 10, 15% advantage? Yeah. So I think to answer this question, let me just ask the audience, like for transportation, how many apps do you have in your mobile phone? Like anyone having more than three apps in the mobile phone for transportation?
10:20Anyone having two apps?
10:21Yes.
10:23Anyone having only one app?
10:25Yes. So you know, in today's world, the apps are also fighting for space in the phone.
10:33Mhm.
10:33Okay. And if you have to go back to that app, there has to be a use case scenario that okay, I need to use this, so that's why I'm going to keep it. If say the milk was not there.
10:48Mhm.
10:49Then the chances of Milkbaskets competing against the likes of Amazon, BigBasket and other Reliance and all that deep discounting platforms was very limited. But with milk as a hook, we had an entry point.
11:06And with that, I think it was one of the best strategies that we were able to employ. And although it was a very low margin business, I would say a zero margin sum game, but what it did was that you were able to open the app again and again. So for 30 days in a month, I'm there at your doorstep. I'm serving in that bag which has the Milkbasket name on it. And again and again I'm reminding you that you have an app in your phone from which you can order your groceries.
11:38What if people started tagging milk with Milkbasket and they would not order any other groceries along with that? See, because what happens is that at times one app gets tunnel vision into only one specific item. For example, there are a lot of apps in the market. In my society, we use migate just to accept or decline the delivery guys coming into our homes or society, right? So was that a risk that you all evaluated when you all started with milk only?
12:05Yeah, definitely we all evaluated that, and that was surely a risk that okay, will it sort of restrict itself to just being a milk app? But that was a very calculated risk. You just started making an app, or you made a, or you bought a ready made app, or you developed a ready made app, or you just went to customers to test the market. Okay, we are here to deliver milk. Next day morning we have started taking orders. So how was that journey? We would like to know more about it, like your first day after deciding on milk as a product. So I think we took about 3 to four months to sort of decide on the basic USPS. Even today we are the only app where there is no checkout feature.
12:47So even on Amazon you have to go and do a checkout. On Milkbasket app you just have to add the product to your basket and it will get delivered to you next day morning.
12:58Okay.
12:58So the uses of the app was made so simple that from a 70 year old man to a 7-year-old kid, all of them can use it. So that is why the customers loved us, right? So in the beginning, if I have to reiterate basically what happened was that when we started, so before we started actually, Anand and Ashish, my other two co-founders, they had already done two, three startups and none of them succeeded, but they definitely had that experience of doing something that didn't work. So we knew that what not to be done, so we didn't waited for the app to go live for everything to be and span and be 100% ready to get into the market. We were there on the very first day standing on the canopy telling the customers that hey, we are here and you know we are this sort of a founder profile, people from INSEAD, people from Exelari, and we are starting this business. All you have to do is give us just 500 bucks and tomorrow morning you will have your milk at your doorstep.
14:07And how were you taking those orders? We were taking it on an Excel sheet. We were just writing it down on a piece of paper. And the first delivery was done by four co-founders and just two delivery boys.
14:20So, I'm so sorry, but see, you told me that INSEAD found Insad alumni, right? You yourself are from Excel. Wasn't it a little bit contradictory that coming from such high backgrounds, you all were actually managing all the orders on Excel sheets for the first what, six, seven months?
14:39Yep.
14:40So how is it different as compared to a normal food today?
14:45So what we were delivering was a promise that your deliveries will happen before 7:00 a.m. in the morning, and that is what we did. We proved them again and again for the next 180 days that your deliveries are happening on time and there are no discrepancies. So we were very customer obsessed, you can say that. We didn't wanted a single escalation, and even if you know sometime something happens, like because we were leaving the products at the doorstep, and that's to milk. So if you think of a high-rise society in Gura, you can think of you know there can be cats also. There can be mates who are walking around during that time, of that period of time between say 4:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. when I have actually delivered the things at the doorstep, and there can be spillage, there can be you know theft. But what we used to ensure was that see, when you are doing a service, then you need to be with, to stand with the customer.
15:49So if say something like that has happened, so instead of blaming each other or instead of you know just processing the refund and saying I'm sorry, what we used to do was that we will buy the milk from the neighborhood stores and give it to the customer so that at least he can have his tea. So Anurag, a very sensitive thing over here. When you have already delivered the milk as per your records, as per your system it's marked as delivered, and then you get a call from a customer saying that he or she hasn't received their supply or their order for the day, how was your reaction over there? Because systems processed order, whether to believe that customer or not, or whether to understand there was a loophole in the system.
16:38Tell us something more about that. See, I think this question basically everyone can relate to it. When you are talking to a local dudwala, you know the dudala bayas and all, they also keep it on a pen and paper, and at the end of the month they used to come and say that okay, now this month you have taken 60 lit or 65 lit of milk and you have to pay this much. I'm sure, rather let me ask you guys, how many of you think that if say the dude is saying that he has delivered 60 lit of milk, is he 100% correct or is he overexaggerating over executing? Okay, because that is where he is getting his margins because he is not getting margins on the milk delivery. So he is just trying to earn his income. So what we did was that we made it very impartial, very transparent, that okay, you had ordered for this much milk and this is what is getting delivered to you. And believe me when I say this, that customers are not cheaters. They are not looking to you know earn money out of your milk delivery, that okay, I've saved 10 rupees by saying a lie. They don't want to do that. And our audience was also like that, because we were delivering in a society which has a residential flat with a up cost of upward of 1 CR. So those people had money. So those people will are not looking for you know cheating the organization.
18:08They are actually looking for service. So you have to trust that customer, and even if say one or two wrong ones come in, you have the system to take care of it, right? And what an irony, I'll tell you. So off the topic only, when you say that customers are looking for service, there was one of the pizza companies who had started deliveries in 30 minutes or else the pizza used to be free. I really did not want to look at the service. I always expected the pizza to come at 31st minute only.
18:35Customer perspective, right? True. But anyways, coming back to the deliveries, were there any instances wherein, it's a painful job, right, early in the morning 4:00 deliveries. I'm sure a person coming out from a premium institute, taking those bag full of milks and then delivering door to door, that would have been painful. But there would have been instances wherein at times your delivery boys, because they are coming for a very short span to work with you, and they don't reach that particular day or time, how would you react and what was the backup plan if this happened, that the deliveries were planned for six people and only four co-founders are there and the two delivery boys did not turn up? What would you do then?
19:14Yeah. So as I mentioned, we were customer offices. So no matter what, delivery has to happen, whether it is four people or 15 people, delivery will happen and delivery will happen on time. So I remember one incident where you know there were rains happening in Gura over the last night, and I got up a call at around 2:00 a.m. in the night saying that the printer has conked up and we are not able to take a print out, and by that time we had grown to more than 200 deliveries. So without a printed sheet it was very difficult. Although the entire journey, the entire society was mapped in the back end, but without a print out it was still difficult. So just think of it. I was you know I said that okay, let me come over there and let me see. In my car I was thinking that where can I get a print out at this point of time and at 2 a.m.
20:12Then I suddenly realized that you know hospitals are working 24/7. So near my warehouse there was a small hospital. I took a bundle of APO sheets and went to him, and with a 500 rupees wrote and told him, sir, you just need to take this print out, and he was you know good enough to help me out and we were able to still deliver before 7:00 a.m. on that night.
20:37Hospital was a lifesaver for you as well.
20:39Definitely. How many careers did you all disrupt in terms of budwas in the six years?
20:46No, I won't say that we had disrupted them. Yes, few of them would have been out of business because of us. But some of them got absorbed into the system. We gave them jobs. Some of them we had you know bad incidences as well, where they were trying to maul or trying to fight with the delivery boys. So we took help from police and the local agencies or even the society RWS to sort those issues, but these things happen. So it's basically when you're trying to make something big, definitely you will have some initial entrances. I'm quite sure those dudalas parents would be happy about it because they moved from level one of their happiness, that their kids being founders. True. Towards you giving them jobs, right?
21:35Yeah, definitely. Yes.
21:37So, run us through a typical operational day in your life, right? The whole job was at night, right? So from the time an order comes from an app, to the time you all place the orders to your vendors, the milk bags come to your warehouses, you'll sort them out and then send them out for delivery. Run us through the complete operational day of that.
21:59See, Milkbasket was a very highly operationally intensive business, and the day and night operations were very different. So the day operations were basically to manage the inventory, because we used to keep the inventory at our warehouse, and even for managing the inventory we had some models wherein even the inventory used to fight among themselves to come into the warehouse. If you are getting my point, basically only the fast-moving items will get placed at the warehouse and we will keep that inventory at a warehouse. But the slow-moving, the long-tail ones, we'll pick them from the neighborhood stores, because for customers they want choice, but at what cost. So we didn't wanted to over keep the inventory and you know had those expenses of expiry and all. So we used to ensure that whatever we are delivering to the customer is in a way that if the customer goes to a grocery store, he is bound to pick that product.
23:06So it is like having sufficient shelf life and it is also in a good condition packet. So that's how we used to behave for the customers. For the night operations, we used to start at about 10:00 p.m., because the orders were finalized only at midnight. So we had this picking, packing and delivery operation. So between at the warehouse from 12 to 4 we will do the pickpack part, and at 4:00 a.m. all the vehicles will get docked at the docking stations. They will get loaded by 4:30 and before 7:00 we will complete all the deliveries. So you would sleep through the entire day and work at night?
23:51No, I didn't used to sleep through the entire day, but yeah, we used to work at night, and even for our investors also we used to take them at 12 midnight to the warehouse because what, for a visit or for a visit, because see, tech is one part but operations was our core area. So unless and until you see the scale of operations, do you see how it is being managed, I think it is difficult to convince the investors. I think in our journey we would have at least taken 10 to 15 investors to the warehouse and then made them have you know Aluga paratram dhaga.
24:27Okay. 2:00 a.m. in the morning.
24:29Okay.
24:30Okay. So let's go behind a bit. You said that you took around 3 months to build your first version of the app.
24:37Yeah. Do you think that was one of your reasons that you went late in the market? You became late in terms of eventually raising your first round, which took around 1 and 1/2 years. If you would have built this app first and then gone to the customers, you would have reduced this timeline might be by a few months more. Yeah, I think that's a possibility. But that also means that I would have started working on the apps at least 6 months earlier.
25:03So it's a chicken and egg kind of a situation. So we from our experience were very clear that we don't want to wait for the app to be 100% live, and we started with a pen and paper and we ensured that the customer is not facing any problems because of that.
25:19Okay. Although it was difficult for us to manage, but yeah, we were able to pull that off, and I think raising it in one and a half years was just a matter of time, because we limited ourselves to the societies that we wanted to service and get to a proof of concept that like with the three societies that we chose in Gura, we were able to reach about 40% plus penetration in all of them. That is where we were able to prove to the investor that this model can work.
25:50If you could put some light on these numbers, like 40% of a society would be what, every society is having what, 500, 600 apartments.
25:57Yeah. In gau luckily we have bigger societies, and the kind of societies that we had chosen, I think on an average there were about 800 to 1,000 flats per societies. So 40% will mean upward of 400 plus customers on the app.
26:13Got it. So just to put this in crisper words for the next set of entrepreneurs to understand, what would be your suggestion in terms of entering the market, whether they should try with a existing app or rather they should build a app, or might be have a product to test the market, or go all in, understand the product and make a supportive system to operate? What would you recommend? See, I think cost, I will take a step back and I will want to these guys to basically understand that they need to focus first on whom, what is a product, and what is it that they are building for. So who are their targeted customers? So unless and until you know that what is your targeted audience, you're never going to make a successful product.
27:04So once you have understood that okay, this is my targeted audience, then you need to understand what is their current pain point, and if you understood the pain point, then you need to ensure that okay, is it a real pain point? That is where you need to test the market. Is it something that it is only in my head, or it is something that people are also resonating with? So once you have done that, I think then only you can think of what sort of product it has to be, what all needs to be done on the tech part. I think all that comes secondary.
27:34Okay.
27:35What, who were your first set of customers? They were from these three societies. How did you convince them to come to you, and we'd love to hear the pitch that you were giving to them, considering that we are the target set of audience that you're going to be selling the link to. What would your pitch be?
27:52And one more thing, we are not friends on this.
27:55Yeah, that pitch is very easy.
27:58True, true, true. No. So I think we were lucky to have wonderful founders team as such, and like when we used to, like I come from a army background, so being an ex-major to becoming a delivery boy for a, or a, for a milk, I think it was quite a journey. And not just that, we were also standing on those canopies doing that marketing, and to tell you a fact, I think Anan's wife, she was pregnant and she was also doing the marketing for us in those initial days. So we were approaching the customers directly telling them about our you know profiles and what we are trying to build, and we would you know, when you have conviction, when you believe in something, then that reflects on how you are speaking to someone, and that is where people are also able to trust us, and we started with those 25 deliveries which we did as four co-founders and just did two delivery. Yes.
29:05So, but can you please throw us a pitch because I have never seen anybody in a pitch as such. I've seen it in movies and all, but not in reality. If I could learn it from experienced people like y'all. I mean, even Koustubh can chip. He's had his own startup also.
29:20Yeah. I think the pitch was quite simple, and you know, just to give you a one-liner over here, I think our pitch was predominantly based on you just have to give us 500 rupees to start with and you will have your milk delivered before 7:00 a.m. in the morning. So that was the key USPS. Other than that, we had you know no delivery charge, no minimum order, one-click ordering, all those tech parts which came in later, but to begin with it was very simple. Your dudala is unreliable. We will deliver you reliably before 7:00 a.m. in the morning each and every day. And in the six years of my journey with Milkbasket, it was just one day when the covid hit and we didn't had permissions that we were not able to deliver. Otherwise all the rest of the days we had delivered, whether it was floods in Gura or anything.
30:15No, I can truly relate to this. So one of my first startups, after immediately after coming out of SCMHRD, was into fresh herbal juices. So I was way ahead of time back then, wherein we were manufacturing those juices and delivering it within two hours of manufacturing, that too without any adding any preservatives and all. So when Jinay asked about the pitch, I was also trying to recollect what was my pitch back then. Then I realized more than the pitch, guys, you know what, it's only the conviction of the founder that customers are looking at, the way you speak and the way you are convinced about your product. I think 50% battle is won over there itself. True. True. And then eventually your efforts. So like in my case, you had four co-founders.
30:57I was the sole founder back then. We did not have mobile applications. We did not have Google maps.
31:02We used to use the same pattern, paper and pen and the list of customers.
31:08True.
31:08I had around seven. We were catering to around 750 odd customers. I still remember we had around five to six delivery guys, and every day one person used to go missing. Might be he has parted way too hard last night, might be has taken up some other job in the morning. And at some point of time I realized that I knew all the houses of 750 customers of mine.
31:32True.
31:32Because I was delivering one route every day.
31:34Yeah.
31:35But that comes with, I think that's the passion for your product, and that's how you are convinced how it will be accepted in the market.
31:42Definitely. I think even my mobile number still remains with more than thousand plus customers, and even after you know leaving Milkbasket for about good 2, 3 years, I used to still getting calls that milk what was your reaction then? Let me see, let me try what you can do.
32:03So you ever had this thing where you know you were going to some person's house to deliver milk, right, and then it's like this is my cousin, so I can't go to his house, so you send somebody like, can you please go and deliver to his house because he's one of my crew's cousins. Have you had that before in Delhi or no?
32:19No, I actually didn't had that, but even if I had to go to a cousin's house, I don't think I will be ashamed.
32:24Very nice.
32:25My next question comes in. This is one of the major problems that people face, especially the young generation, when they want to get into something key. We know that we are getting into a product that we want to build. We have a conviction that this will work. But then the journey, how long will it take for me to reach there? Nobody knows. And the way we started you, everyone has a fixed number in their mind that I can pull it off for so many months or so many months can be my runway. You started and after that raised funds almost one and a half years later. Did you ever think that it will take me one and a half years to raise funds for this particular product, or you had something else in the mind and then you had to pull yourself all together on a different path to make the ends meet?
33:16Yeah, I think when we started, to be honest, I really didn't had any idea what a startup is. I didn't knew that you know it's going to take so long, or it's going to be such a remarkable journey where wherein your household finances will go for a toss, you know, there is pressure from everywhere and you are battling with yourself as well, whether you have taken the right decision or not, well, because before that I was working with Samsung electronics and it was a 9 to-five job, 5 days a week. I don't think I had ever had that in my life before. So my wife was pretty happy and content with what I was doing back then.
33:58But I would sort of give it up to my wife that she supported me throughout the journey and was always there for me. And I think when you're doing a startup, it is like raising a baby. And when you already have one or two babies at your home and now you're trying to raise another one, it takes a toll on you. So that journey becomes very very difficult. So there was a time, after I think about 10 months into the journey, we were sitting at a Starbucks, all the four co-founders, and we had literally no cash in the bank on from whatever we had put in as our initial money to run this business. We did had some commitments from an investor, but that was taking time, and believe me when I say this, that any commitment is a commitment only if the money lands in your bank account.
35:01M So you're not very sure about it. So we were discussing whether we need to deliver tomorrow or not, but we unanimously I think decided that okay, we have it and we will manage it somehow and we will keep going. And from that day I think, once the funding came in, we actually did never look back. Okay, I'll come back to this again in my next question. But before we move over there, now I want to understand more from a family perspective. From your first month of starting up towards your 18th month over there, what were the compromises that your family made? Because the cash in hand would have started shrinking, shrinking, and 100% from you, your wife to your kids, there would have been things that would have been continuously changing month on month.
35:51True. Would you like to discuss something about it? Yeah, I think it's a difficult journey to be in, and that too at a stage because when I started I think my age was about 36 years, and at that point of time you definitely have responsibilities and you are sort of at the peak of your career, and then jumping into something to start from scratch, build from zero ground, it's really difficult to take that leap of faith. But once decided, I think we were fully committed that we want to hold on to this idea, and we had conviction that this model is going to work because we were seeing the numbers were growing, the customers were loving it, we had cracked the code on how to deliver, how to manage the inventory, how to manage the operations. So all those progresses we have made, plus from the tech side also we were making quite a sustainable progress with very very limited resources.
36:54So that way things were falling in place and we were confident that we will pull it through.
36:59But in this case, do you remember something, might be a single no, that might have disheartened your kid because of this situation, or your family, or yourself also? Okay, I want to buy this, I need this, but I can't buy this because of my commitment towards Milkbasket. No. So I won't say that we compromise on our needs, but yes, we compromise on our wants.
37:22So luxury was out of question, but yeah, needs were never compromised. So at least that much I had it. See, I'll tell you a funny instance over here. How entrepreneurship works is way too different. It looks so rosy from outside. I remember when I started Ressy. So first round we exhausted immediately because you start hiring, you have number of marketing campaigns which are lined up, and then one of my co-founders in Ressy, he left in the first 6 months. Then I had another co-founder Kulp who joined me as a CTO in Ressy. Now the funny bit was we were almost exhausting all of our funds and we had the commitment of the next round, and I was not taking any salaries for four to 5 months.
38:05I have hired my friend as a CTO, he is supposed to join 1 and a half months later because the funding is going to hit my account 15 days from now, and I am calling him to ask, Kulp, can you please transfer me 50,000 rupees because I am completely broke at this point of time. And he was also so comfortable saying that Haro, what happened, the funding has not yet hit you? No, it's not about funding, it's been like last 4 months that I have not even drawn any salaries, and the commitment towards joining a product or a organization is so that a person knows that the CEO and the founder has not drawn any salaries and he's joining him as a CTO in next one and a half months with the commitment from investors from whom the money has not yet reached the account.
38:48True.
38:48But yes, it's always about the commitments and the convictions that work, I think, particularly when you want to be an entrepreneur. Yes, you were saying something. No, no. What I was saying is that you don't go to your parents to ask for money, or what I mean, for one rate goes wrong on my demat and I go back to my dad saying that I don't need so much.
39:08Parents are always your failsafe option, but that is I think the last to last offer option that you want to try.
39:15So you want to do something on your own, that's a decision that you have made.
39:19So you need to sort of stand to that and make it out somehow. So you know, in Milkbasket journey we had such a good model that even our customers liked it and they also wanted to you know be part of the journey itself. So that's where you know the conviction slowly and gradually starts building up. As Koustubh mentioned, like initial hiring and getting a CTO or getting someone who actually believes in your model and is ready to work without any salary, I think that's the most difficult part. But once you have the right team in place, I think then there's no stopping, and my two cents on that, you cannot build consumer tech businesses on your parents money, guys. You are spending what, a few lakh rupees every day, so don't even think about this, guys. That's not even the last option. Okay, so moving ahead, so first one and a half years you were catering to only three societies. The conversation between you founders also, Anurag, would have been different, right? First four five months it would have been always like we will list it in less than 5 years, we will become a billion dollar company, we will cater to a million orders every day, all those heavy words. But till the end of 18 months the conversation would have moved clearly to survival mode by chalana what you rightly said, what the discussion at the Starbucks that you had to take a call whether you wanted to continue your Milkbasket journey further, or you have you had to take a call over there.
40:57Now how was the change in conversations affecting you as founders and your relations? It always would have started with Anand and the team completely, because Anand I think he was leading the entire co-founding team as a CEO.
41:12Yeah. So how was Anan's role over here in terms of motivating rest of the co-founders and how were you aligning yourself with the rest of the team from first thought of taking it public in less than 5 years to chall Yeah, I think Anan's role was quite pivotal, and he was the powerhouse behind Milkbasket, because he was managing the investor relations, getting thus the funding and you know taking us to each of the phases that we faced. So I think definitely when you are at the mode of survival, the conversations do change and there is bound to be little bit of distrust, disbelief and all those factors coming in, friction that started coming in as well.
42:07Also, I won't say little in terms of friction, but yeah, discussions will happen, right?
42:13So that way, because there are so many lives which are associated with it. Your own family, your own you know survival, or whether you want to continue this or do you want to go back to working in a stable job or stable environment. So that sort of self-doubts and those things will definitely creep in, but I think we were lucky enough to have one of the other ray of hope coming in and hitting us at the right moment. So we were able to continue. So I truly believe that running a surv, I think 102 things need to go right, and even if one thing goes wrong then you're doomed to be a failure.
42:59Mhm.
42:59So but I don't understand one thing at all. So what I have heard is that VCs or investors, right, they fund growth usually, right?
43:07You all stayed in three societies for 1.5 years.
43:10Yeah. So was staying small a strategy in your case, or were you all simply not able to expand?
43:17No. So you have to understand, Jinay, when you are starting up and you are you know hiring a team and building something, working on the tech, working on operations, setting out inventory, setting up warehouses, so everything eats up money and you're working with limited resources. Currently you are just working with your own capital. So there is like even if you want to do marketing, you want to hire Shah Rukh Khan, it's not going to happen.
43:42So what is going to happen is that you yourself are standing at the canopy with the conviction that yes, I can get at least 10 customers onboarded today. And then our service was so good that we had more than 35% of our customers coming through word of mouth, because I'm there every day in the morning in the society with the vehicle delivering to those households. So the neighbor is not getting but you are getting the stuff. So you know the neighbor will definitely ask or at least notice that someone is delivering every day. So operationally it was very challenging, but yes, we were able to pull that off. Then investment wise was that these relations only. Okay. By the way, let me just tell the audience over here. So Milkbasket and the team were privileged enough to source one of their first funding rounds by their, not investors, customers.
44:36They were one of the only company, I would say, who scored who secured the first funding from their customers as such. Yes. So there was part of few customers who actually wanted to fund us and they formulated an LLP to sort of invest into the So then tell me one thing, Anurag. You were having your investor discussions, and then the customer connect was so deep that customers were willing to invest in your product, whereas investors were taking time, whose profession, whose work is primarily investing in high growth companies. So what do you recommend to the new startup founders or new age entrepreneurs, that should they be committed so much to their customers that their customers will eventually fall in love with the product and be willing to invest in it, or focus their energies on raising funds from investors? See, I think there is a saying that you know you should not be chasing investment. You should be chasing your product, and if the product is good and if the product is you know making the customers fall in love with the product, then the investors will start chasing you, and if it is happening the other way around, then I think you have done what you need to do.
45:54So initially it sounds difficult, but once it, and also it takes time, so it's not going to happen in a 6 months journey, but yeah, once you are able to constantly and constantly prove, like when I say that for 18 months we were restricted to just three societies, so it was not because of anything else but because of the factor that we wanted to prove our model and have that proof of concept that yes, we can grow in these societies. And to be honest, I think we all we did post that was replicate that model to not just three societies but I think more than 400 societies in Delhi NCR plus Hyderabad, Bangalore. So all those places that we went, it was just replica of what we were doing earlier.
46:42Plus definitely we improved on the marketing side. So earlier we were doing only the offline marketing, but then we introduced digital marketing as well, because now the scale was good enough to handle digital marketing.
46:55Okay. So but Anurag, how do you build a customer base of that sort that is so convinced to invest, let's say, 2 CR in your business? Because so I'll give you one example right now, comet, right, a shoe brand. It has launched a shoe in which you can sketch, this is an orange shoe and you can peel it off, right? So this is something that makes a community for a brand, right? Somebody who's crazy behind such a brand because of their innovation. Now milk doesn't have so much innovation. So how do you build that customer base in such a boring segment also?
47:30See, I think you have to differentiate between a customer and an investor.
47:36So customers are someone who are using your product or services and they are falling in love with what you're doing. But the investor is someone who is looking at the business model, who is looking at the revenues, who are looking at the numbers that okay, I have seen them grow, you know, like you're raising your kid, so from 0 to 2 years you have seen him you know from being in your hands to be able to walk. So that is where they were also relating to the journey of Milkbasket, and then they were seeing that yes, they have now started to walk and very soon they are going to run, because we in just 5 years time we became the market leaders in a niche segment that we cater to, right? So post that now I think first one and a half years, I'm quite sure all of us are on the same page now in terms of understanding what were the initial struggles, how did you scale up, why were you confined only to those three societies. You built up your PMF in the right possible manner, convinced your customers in such a way that they were willing to, rather they invested in your organization. Now let's move ahead towards the next journey. 2 years, 300 crores raised and spent, moving from 1,000 orders per day to around 1 lakh orders per day. That's a massive jump. How did you plan these things? I'm quite sure this wouldn't have been planned in a single night or a fortnight.
49:01Yeah.
49:02But when you started visualizing, the first round of funding came around 3 million types in the month of Jan 2018 and then you received around 7 million in 6 months. Can you just tell us more about how this spend was planned from a operations perspective? Okay. When you raise funding, okay, first few months we are going to do this. This funding is going to help us reach over there. What are these calculations? We want to understand from your perspective as such.
49:32Understood. So basically cost of I think Milkbasket was one of the unique companies wherein I actually had the ability to control the company's growth as well.
49:49So when I say that, I mean that like if even if it was operational in Gura, it was not that we were serving the entire Guranga or anyone can order from us. We chose the societies, the clusters, the condominiums where we wanted to service, and that is where we were able to stimulate the growth in the manner that we wanted to grow further. The kind of funding that we had, the kind of amount that we wanted to spend, because we now had the playbooks, we were hiring people, we were hiring resources, we had a marketing team, we had more than 100 plus people in the tech and product side. So the team was growing and now you know this was not just about four founders doing something. There were whole departments who were helping us out and we had a wonderful, amazing team at Milkbasket who have actually seen, I think, if not less, more than five office shifts.
50:47Okay. As we grew, like we started small but then as we grew we started shifting to near office, bigger offices space, even from a warehouse perspective. When we started I think we started with a 500 ft² warehouse, the next one was a 15,000 ft², the next one was a 50,000t warehouse, and the time span between these growth was this was like once we started hitting funding, I think within 1 to one and a half years we were able to pull off that kind of a growth. And that is where you know the exponential growth had happened. So that's where lot of spending also happened and we were planning for further growth. Obviously from 1,000 to one lakh it doesn't happen overnight, but more than about 3 lakh square ft of space.
51:35Wow.
51:36With more than 2500 people working at the warehouse and more than 200 employees at the HO.
51:432500 people working at the warehouses. So these were including the delivery guys.
51:48This was including the delivery guys. But the delivery guys were divided into two parts. One was the full-time workforce that will actually come in the night at about 10 p.m. in the night and will stay with us for the entire night and deliver till 7:00 a.m.
52:03Okay.
52:04And then there were part-time employees. So almost 60% of the workforce was part-timers who will only come during the delivery part and they will handle the deliveries.
52:15Okay. Yeah.
52:16So you had approximately what 250 CR plus funding, right? So anytime you had 50 to 100 crores sitting in your account, being a Gujarati I would blow my brains down thinking that there's so much money in my account first of all. Secondly, who's going to manage that much money, because I won't trust anybody else other than me managing that. How was it bifocated in your team?
52:36I think in corporates or in startups generally you hire a CFO to do all that for you. So we definitely had a CFO and we were parking little bit of funds into some assets which was like for a short term where we were not utilizing that money for that particular duration of time, but otherwise most of what was being spent on the growth phase.
53:03So do you get to decide where to spend money or not? So No, it was a joint decision. So we had a board of directors, we had some investors also on the board. So we will you know chalk out the plan for next six months and basis that we will grow. So just to tell you an example, I think when we decided on going to Hyderabad and Bangalore, so Mumbai was never on the cards.
53:29So why was this? I was like quite curious.
53:33South Bombay is never on cards for any startup at the start. We still don't have Toronto in our areas. Right. No, but by the way, South Bombay reminds me of one of our discussions, Anurag, at the time of Zepto.
53:45Yeah, we said that we will launch Zepto at the end in South Bombay, and the reason behind that is might be a hypothesis, might be a reality, that every house in South Bombay has their chu who can actually go and get the materials whenever you want to.
54:01So that's why I think Pronto, there's a reason why it is not there, or snap it, or might be initial days of Zepto also while we were not there. So I think Jinay knows the answer problem. Exactly. Exactly. Right. So now in one of the podcasts Anand mentioned that postco your business double tripled but then suddenly you had started facing cash shortages, cash crunches, and then there was a news article also which mentioned that senior staff salaries were reduced or rather cut to half also at times, postcoid only. So what went wrong over here, that your business had started booming initially, you required capital, the capital was there on the table, then you required growth, postco your growth triggered, so from 50,000 orders to almost 1 lakh, 1 lakh 10,000 orders per day, and then suddenly you are saying that you are facing cash crunch. The story shouldn't, shouldn't the story have been like this, that after the growth there were investors who would be, who would have lined up in order to invest in your business?
55:10Yeah, definitely. That's what we were also expecting and that's why we grew to the levels that we did, and because we were doing contactless grocery delivery from 2015, I think when COVID happened that was the need of the hour. That was what every government organization or anyone was you know wanting, and I feel privileged and honored to be part of that organization which was able to deliver the groceries to the households without them moving out of the household, and definitely our revenues also doubled. But with covid I think the only sad part that happened was the investor sentiments had also gone down, because the situation was so dynamic, investors were also not looking to bet anymore on these sort of businesses.
56:03Okay. So that's where I think things went wrong, and although even after being the market leaders we were not able to raise the next round of funding, and that's why the cash crunches and other things started to happen.
56:17Okay. I think but that's part of a startup life. You are never sure about what is going to happen.
56:23Yeah. Yeah. Like I said earlier, for a startup to be you know 100% successful, all 102 things need to go right. Leave just one thing going wrong and you're doomed for failure.
56:34True. That reminds me of again one more instance of from one of my startups, Ressy, which got acquired by it. So a very funny thing, the discussions for acquisition started in the month of August.
56:46Yeah.
56:46And after the first meeting itself we are so sure that the acquisition is going to happen, because both of us are in sync with respect to the deliverables and the receivables coming on the table, being exchanged on the table. So I was under the impression that this deal will go through by the month of October, and I had capital in my bank to pay salaries till the month of December.
57:07From August till October nothing moved, not even a single, not even a single, what should I put it, percentage of movement when it comes to deal structuring.
57:18Yeah.
57:18In the month of October their team visited from Singapore to India and then the deal discussion started taking place. On 24th December I realized that I have money only till the month of January and not December to pay to the employees, and I have to take action because at the speed at which this particular deal making process is going, this is going to take another 2 to 3 months. On 24th evening I called up my team, I told them that guys, this is the situation, now we have no other option than to cut down our salaries. The entire team, around 35 36 6 employees, decided proactively to cut down their salaries by 50%. None of the employee left the organization for next 4 months till the time the acquisition happened, and post acquisition then we paid them their accrued salaries for last 4 months.
58:15But yes, these kinds of these kind of things happen in organizations. The kind of spirit that you inculcate in your initial team is something that matters a lot. See, sacrificing 50% salary for your organization and you don't know whether this deal will go through or not. It's just the conviction that with which you are going ahead. Superb. So moving to the last bit of our discussion, Anurag, 4 years, 5 years, 6 years struggling, first one and a half years no money was about crisis, I ken again cash crunch, then again salary cutting. When it came to the execution in these six years, or when you got acquired rather, did you make any money out of the acquisition that would have made you happy for all the sacrifices put in for 6 months? I don't think that it's something that would have sort of accounted for all the sacrifices and all the efforts done, but yeah, we all were able to you know return the investors money, we were able to still pay the salaries, and Milkbasket is still alive even today. I'm getting all my grocery deliveries through Milkbasket only. The loyalty you still keep. I am still loyal customer. Very nice, but including the opportunity cost of 6 years, you would say that is positive or negative.
59:36See, some questions are better unanswered. And you know, I got the answer. See, it's a learnings. It's a journey that you need to enjoy. So, solid. Yeah. Very nice.
59:58But then do you measure your success only by finance? See, I'll tell you anything that I see around me today, right? Everything is measured only by financial gains, at least in this era, right? If you're making money, if you're putting on good clothes, wearing the nicest watches around, you're making money, you're settled in life. As for you, is financial gain the only success metric, or is building a beautiful product that is now used by crores of people in the world in India is a success metric?
1:00:32I think everyone of the audience will also know the answer here. How many of you believe that only a financial gain makes for a successful matrix? And how many of you believe that a good product can also be a successful matrix?
1:00:50Thank you.
1:00:51Thank you for your support.
1:00:55First say so, to basically answer your question, I think yes, financial gain is important because you know you have put in so much of effort, so much of sweat and blood into it, and it's literally blood when I say that. So you know financial gain is something that will actually justify your that much of effort, years and years of effort. So yes it matters a lot, but I still believe that if you are able to do something which can change the industry or which can have an impact on people's life, I think that's a bigger motivator. So before we close, most of the people here don't know that you were also a part of the founding team for Zepto along with cost observe spill out some secrets from the early days, something that made Zepto what it is today.
1:01:51We all know it is going for IPO.
1:01:53Yes. So I think post Milkbasket I got an opportunity to work for Zepto as a consultant, and that is where I worked with Koustubh as well, and we were part of the initial core team at Zepto and we were sort of building their dark stores and establishing the model how the quick commerce is supposed to work. I think there was an incident in Koustubh, if you remember it more than me, that there was some order from some celebrity which oh, I know the one that K also mentioned at one of his recent podcast. So I'll tell you guys, by the way, before we move ahead, just a couple of pictures. These pictures are very iconic pictures because what Zepto you use today, I know it's so popular, everyone uses it. This is the first picture wherein the first store at Bandra had its materials unloaded at the store, the left picture. So you can see Adita over there, you can see Ki behind, you can see Anuragi, then you have Shoubam as well as Yashuag in the initial members. This is inside the dark first dark store of Zepto wherein the store had not gone live, and you remember we were testing the WMS, the warehouse management system over there. So quite iconic photos, something I really cherish, we really cherish about them.
1:03:13Okay, moving back to that funny incident what KV mentioned recently. Kavalier. So on one of the podcast he mentioned that there was a order from a actress and there was a discussion going on who will go and deliver that order. So he never answered who delivered that order.
1:03:31So back then Koustubh was even more handsome.
1:03:35I had, can you see me in beard? So we started discussing because both of us were in the Bandra warehouse, and Bandra warehouse was catering, was in a serviceable radius of most of the Bollywood stars over there. So me and Anurag, and again the order, I knew that it was from a star, a very very senior actress as such, and then we started discussing, Anurag, who will go and deliver this order. Let's go with the delivery guy just to understand the service levels. So because we never wanted to look like delivery guys over there, right? He's not telling the truth. So me on my, I took one of the delivery riders bike, Anurag sitting behind the rider. We go to the apartment. Both of us like before entering also opening our cameras and seeing as if this actress is going to come and speak with us.
1:04:25We reached the gate. The gate opened this much. They asked, yes, Zepto, please pass it. They took the order and the gate was closed. That was our experience, right?
1:04:37So where did this Bollywood circle connection come from? Because I've heard it in so in our circle also we heard that Zepto became famous because it was introduced in the Bollywood circle somewhere around San.
1:04:49Yeah.
1:04:51So I'll tell you the story behind this thing. This particular store only when it opened it, we opened this at Chum village, which is just besides Pali Hill. So when the store was opened, I have one of my friends called as Nikl Namit, a very dear friend of mine from school, classmates from Xavier's. So when we wanted to test this before the app went live, we wanted to test how fast we can deliver, right? Are we actually delivering in 10 minutes? So I told my friend to test this, place a test order, and he was really surprised and shocked. He's like minute, how is this even possible? Then he's convincing me that Koustubh, I think this is by mistake. You would have, you would have sent this, you would have packed this in the fastest possible time. I want to place this again. And then this thing started spreading. So what Nikl did, Nikl told us, he's very close to Atulagni Utri's family.
1:05:44He's the one who has produced movies like Bodyguard and Bhat. He's a producer and director of both the movies. And then that thing he started telling his friends. So I remember he telling Sohil Khan's son to place the order. Then all that film fraternity to just to place their first orders and check whether they are getting it in 10 minutes, and then when they got their orders and then when they started getting their orders in under 10 minutes, they started becoming like a statement because the product was so good. They also started setting examples or giving examples to whoever came to their house.
1:06:18I let me show you something. What do you want to have, a Red Bull? Give me a second. They placed order for Red Bull. 5 minutes, Red Bull is at the doorsteping. But the product was so good, right? Nobody had expected to get your orders delivered in like 5 to 7 minutes, and that thing worked. So once they started posting about it, so half of the posting or marketing for Zepto which was done in the initial days was through these circles by putting their status on WhatsApp or Insta and then imagine such celebrity profiles putting up statuses without, and that's a non-paid marketing, right? That's completely organic. The kind of grip the product got, I think that was fantastic. That was superb.
1:06:58I think that's an example of you know what the product can do. If you're designing the right product then you actually don't need to spend on marketing. Your customers will do it for you.
1:07:06Right.
1:07:08Perfect. I think this was a great discussion. Thank you so much for coming in. Just one night before we move, just in one night, what went wrong?
1:07:18The timing.
1:07:19The covid hit and you know the investor sentiment died down, so that's why we were not able to scale further. Superb. Thank you so much, Anurag, for your time over here. It was really a pleasure having you. I'm quite sure, guys, this would have been a different kind of discussion in front of you, right? Had you ever imagined founders or co-founders while execution they have to go to such depths, they have to solve such difficult task? I'm quite sure you would have not, or rather, let's keep it open for questions and Yeah, yeah, sure.
1:07:53Anurag would be more than happy to take questions. Please, guys, ask. Good afternoon, sir. I'm a first market student. While you were running the company, were there moments when you realized that there was the most important decision taken without you being in the room?
1:08:09Yeah, I think there would have been certain moments like that, because I was not part of all the investors related discussions. They used to flow down from Anand, and there were some pretty decent discussions which had happened towards the later stage of the startups. So yeah, that would have happened, but you know, that being said, it's also not possible for a four founder team to be always present in each and every discussion. So what used to happen is that once say the discussion has happened at the investor level or some VCs level or something, then we will always have some sort of a joint meeting and in that we will discuss the pros and cons of what has been sort of offered, and then we will take a joint decision.
1:08:56So it was always a collective effort.
1:08:59Good afternoon, sir. Thank you so much for the session today. My name is Gas. I just wanted to ask you, so I just read recently that before the Reliance deal happened there were talks with BigBasket and Amazon, if I'm not wrong. So when the Reliance deal actually happened, was that the best deal that you had on the table?
1:09:20I think that in hindsight I cannot say that was the best deal that happened, but at that point of time it was best for the company and for the interest of the employees to have that. Hi sir, thank you for the session. I wanted to ask like there are many brands like Country Delight is there, Festo Home is there. So if Milkbasket also had the packaging on the products while delivering, want to, don't you think that would have scaled better?
1:09:45Yeah, definitely that would have scaled better, but that's a different business model altogether. So what Milkbasket was essentially doing was that we were a more of a logistics and a tech company wherein we were just replacing your physical dudala with an online technology based platform on which you can place an order and get the stuff delivered. So we didn't own a single brand to you know create a market for that or to product to channelize that, but private label is something that we always considered, and I think that that was a miss for us. We could have become bigger in on private label category because there the margins are much better. Sir, I'm singing from first year sales and marketing.
1:10:36Yeah. So, so my question is that if I had to start a company next year and I had to sign my first shareholder agreement with the investor, so what is the clause that I should never forget to mention, or if you were at my stage, so what you would have done?
1:10:56I think that's a very valid question. You know, as founders you are supposed to be jack of all trades and you are supposed to be know it all types. Okay. But that's not practically possible. So if say you are a sales and marketing guy or if you are an operations guy, you need to excel in your field. And wherever you don't have the 100% of the knowledge, I think then you should always go back to the experts in that field to get that know-how. So I think while drafting a shareholder agreement, there are not one but many many clauses and each of those clauses are very relevant, like say there can be a drag along right, there can be a right to first refusal, okay, or liquidation preferences.
1:11:46So all these terminologies you will probably not even understand. So that is where you need to consult a legal expert and get their understanding to be able to draft those agreements which becomes little bit founder friendly. It should not be one-sided. That's the only motive. See, investor also when he is putting his money, he wants to safeguard his interest. So it's not wrong for him to safeguard his interest, but at the same time he should not be you know overkilling the rights of the founders. So that's one thing that you need to keep in mind. See, my two cents over here would be get a good lawyer. We end up saving so much in saying that aa, he is charging me two lakh rupees for a shareholder agreement. That two lakh is truly worth it if he's a good lawyer and if he's a seasoned lawyer.
1:12:40A young lawyer out of a college, might be two years experience, can execute that, might be for 10,000 or 15,000 also. But that few lakh rupees don't matter in the initial days, because if you don't invest that, you have no clue how it will come and pinch you in the worst possible manner when you don't want it to after a few years. So always go with the experienced lawyer who has executed deeds, who has executed, who's worked closely with founders on SHAs, who has been from the founder side also, not only from the investor side, so that the clauses are beneficial for both the founders and the investors.
1:13:17Thank you so much for addressing us today. My question is, you know, from the task, what were the learnings that you had after your entire journey that you actually you know used and incorporated in your early days in the sector?
1:13:35What do you do differently from your past during your early days?
1:13:39See, it's not about doing something different. It's basically using your experience to build something better. So Milkbasket was a different model where we were sort of collecting all the orders throughout the day. We actually you know sort of scrapped the grocery list, the shopping list that earlier people used to make and all those stuff. But with Zepto and the new age platforms for quick commerce, I think what has changed is that now there was no planning. Now it is instant. So when it is instant, then what matters the most is that the promise that you're making to the customers. Like in Milkbasket we were saying that delivery before 7:00 a.m. Here we are saying delivery within 10 minutes. So which means that I need to now break down those 10 minutes and understand that how much time I'm going to take in the warehouse for picking and packing, and how much time I'm going to take for the actual delivery partner to be able to run from the warehouse to the customer's house.
1:14:47So which means I need to be very near to the customer's house. So that way you know the entire structuring of the warehousing and the supply chain and the way we pick pack in the warehouse, everything changed. So the model evolved as per that. See, from my side, if I have to tell last 15 years of my experiences in building startups, I have always built companies wherein we had a constraint on some of the other thing, majorly finances. So we had a limited finance when you are building something, you raise around, you have a fixed set of runway, fixed days or fixed months of runway that you execute on. With Zepto it was never the case. Adith always had access to, or rather the company always had access to funds, and Adith always had access to his only vision that I need precision, guys, no matter at what cost. When you have that kind of confidence coming in that okay, you don't worry about the finances, we know in the initial days we'll do mistakes, but do those mistakes as fast as you can, we are here to bear it at this point of time. So that gave a lot of scope in terms of trying, testing things, achieving success, seeing failures, and then figuring it out at a right model wherein we could fit everything in under 10 minutes of deliveries. So I think for me especially, if you ask me, that freedom came that came with capital. When it comes, when you talk about execution power, your execution power suddenly dramat increases to a different level altogether. So I think that was one of the main inputs from my side, I would say, when it comes to executing Zepto and how we could do that in less than 10 minutes. Yeah, cuz I believe that even with Zepto, I don't think that Adit you know hastily did anything. Yes, it was more of a planned way in which you know we did our first warehouse and we were doing this deliveries from that and you know testing those 10 minutes, under 10 minutes ordering deliveries happening or not, getting the customer feedbacks, and once we were sure that okay, now this model is working and people are loving it, then only we started expanding to other places.
1:16:57Good afternoon, this is a host sales and marketing. So as you said that Milkbasket is more on the operational side and the logistic side, milk adulteration is one of the major concerns in India. So how are you guys maintaining quality assurance, saying that each and every customer is going to get better milk and not treatment in India, where is one of the concern, like people say, so how maintaining that? Yeah, I think that was again one of the problems with the local dudalas, when you are taking from them and if you are taking local milk actually village and you know bwalas, they come with the dulus and all, so that is where the adulteration happens the maximum, or at place it's supposed to happen. But with Milkbasket we were delivering the best of the best brands. So in north India like Amul and Vader are the two big names, in Bangalore side, Nandini is a very big brand.
1:17:59So we were official distributors for these brands and so these was all packet milk plus, so there's no point of adulteration happening on those packets, and what we used to ensure was that we used to deliver the same day that we are procuring. So the shelf life used to be there for the customer, because it's not necessary that if you purchase the milk today you're going to consume it today itself. So we wanted to have the customer the same experience as they are procuring it themselves. Plus what we also did was that we had a lot of lot many startups also coming on our platform because we were a logistics and supply chain platform. So they get access to premium customers. So companies like 4S milk and other bottled plant milk. So white farms and other things.
1:18:44So they will come and list on our platform, and there also we used to ensure that the quality is of a premium certain you know level, then only we will list them, otherwise we will not.
1:18:57We are very much thankful for this such a wonderful session. So my question is that adding a prepaid world model at that early stage was really a great bold move for you. So but considering the fact that the customers weren't that much familiar to that model, how difficult was you for you to convince during your pitching time to the consumers?
1:19:17I think that was one of the biggest you know foundations for Milkbasket, because we had this prepaid wallet, and even today I think the dudalas they work on the post-paid model. So milk traditionally worked on that postpaid model only, but once we were able to convince our customers that you have to pay in advance, what it did for us was that we always had positive working capital from the customer side and we actually didn't have to run after customers to get the money after the months end or something. So that way it was difficult initially, but once they start using the service and once they you know experience it, or even if you are not experiencing it yourself but your neighbor is doing that and he is reaping the benefits, then you also wonder that okay, now I can also do and try it.
1:20:09So I think that's why I said that word of mouth also helped a lot, more than 35% of our customers they come through that. I'd like to thank you for coming here. Also would like to thank you for serving our country as a major.
1:20:21Thank you.
1:20:21And first question is, coming from army background, did it play a pivotal role in getting a corporate exposure? And means there is certain discipline which comes with army, did it play a role in it? And to Koustubh as well, coming from SCMHRD and getting right out to creating businesses. So did this play a huge role in your life? Anurag, you want to answer first?
1:20:45Yeah. So like army there is a saying you know you join them as a boy and you come out as a man. So army do make men out of you, and I think I was very lucky that post my civil engineering I immediately got to join the armed forces. Although there's also a story over there that you know I got into SPA school of planning and architecture in New Delhi for doing a postgraduate course, but I left that in between, and when I got selected for the armed forces, so I went and joined there. So I think with that kind of an experience, because the leadership and the qualities, the discipline, the integrity that army teaches you, I personally don't feel that any other organization teaches you that well. So that really helped me a lot during the entire journey, and even the course that I did from Exel that was a post-graduate program which was specially designed for the armed forces veterans.
1:21:54So that again helped me because actually when I came out I was thinking that you know I will follow CAT and do a 2 years MBA program. But by the time I was married and you know if you think of going from being a salaried employee to doing a 2 years of program, I think again you have to think of finances. So that journey also helped me, and after doing about 9 years in the corporate world, when we started Milkbasket again that conviction was there that okay, this is something that we can build, not because of so for us here, we never called SCMHRD's finest or best residential business school. We always called this as the best regimental business school, because that's how our routine was back then. So subusur himself was an army plan.
1:22:48Our non-ACADs used to start at 6:00. Our lectures used to start at 9:00. They used to end at 9:00 p.m. Post that we had two to three times a week we had guest lectures. Then everyone was associated with some of the other committee. We used to end our day around 1:30, 2:00 from the campus. Then we had assignments to be completed. So my average sleeping tenure in SCMHRD was not more than 3 hours. So today whatever we are at this point of time, I clearly say that it's only because of the institute, because the institute things that have been taught to me by the institute, we are clearly taking them forward. Without that it won't be possible at all. So I don't know if you guys are living the same regimental life or not, but for us it was way too different. I think that coming from a engineering background, from a extremely casual background to a structured living, that changed a lot of things.
1:23:40First year, within the first month, you won't believe this, by the way, so my sister is over here, you can ask her, first month after first month I went back home crying saying that I can't join this college again. Yes, because the number of lectures that I had attended in the first year itself were way too much than all the lectures attended by me in my engineering course. So I said that I can't do this. So my mom answered me only one with only one word, I think that changed my life for forever. She said that okay, where would you stay? So I got the answer. So I picked up my bag, came back again, and then ensured that we had ensure that we have a great time over here.
1:24:22But yes, because it was first month, but after that we got so much connected with the institute. So my colleague, my batchmate Neil is also over here. Since the time we are here in Njadi yesterday, we have been so nostalgic about the campus, about our life over here. We have been visiting the places, our own places where we used to frequent back then, those days Mazan Noa Tamiji Sak, there used to be a place called talkabout, by the way. How many of you guys know that Faso's second outlet was in hijabi? How many of you guys know that FO's co-founder is alumni of SCMHRD, so has inculcated so many things amongst us. I think every individual would have a different story altogether, but yes, we truly cherish us being a part of SCMHRD. Since the time I have gone to Bombay I have not been frequenting the college, but yes, earlier whenever I used to be in Pune, whenever I was in Pune, I used to ensure that I attend all the events, cultural festival, we used to ensure that we sneak in somehow, spend some time over here, relive our memories and then move out. So that's how we are still connected with the organization.
1:25:30Technically he's so connected, he's been crying every since yesterday that we he both of. Hello, sir, thank you so much for such an insightful session. I am a kanga from business analytics. So in your experience, has such publicity, if it's negative let's say, has it impacted in fundraising or Oh, 100%. Yeah, 100%. See, but you have to understand this thing, there are some planted news as well. It's not only one way news, negative news impact 100% true, but it goes other way around also, like whenever a organization is getting into a fundraising mode they tend to flood the market with positive news as well. So you might see suddenly few companies for a span of a few weeks you start seeing a surge in terms of the news articles by them, you start seeing influencers talking about them, you start seeing Insta post coming on them. Every article, every other article you'll start seeing mention of theirs. So these things they are as a plan of your marketing strategy when it comes to building your PR, because based upon PR it's all human psychology, right? How much you read, what kind of new news you read about that organization, based on that the negotiations tend to be influenced. But yes, every investor also has his own thought process, they have their own due diligences, no matter what news you spread in the market. Negativity influences a when it comes to negotiations, but when you want to induce that positivity, then it takes a lot of efforts for the founders to build that positivity in the market.
1:27:16To add to that, I think I personally believe that you know in marketing no marketing is bad marketing, so no sort of bad publicity also can actually do harm to the company. But when you're talking specifically from a investor relation perspective, yes, that can have a little bit of impact that the sentiments might die down, but all the investors they are also not so naive and they do their due diligence, and that's where they will come to know the in actual intricacies of it, and probably if they feel it fine then they will go ahead with the investment. Perfect. I think thank you so much guys for taking out time. Thank you, Anurag, once again for being a part of this. I hope you like, guys, like the conversation. We will engage more and more founders in the next few episodes.
1:28:10You'll be able to see us on What Went Wrong. You can follow us channel B. So you will see that in next few days or so. But yes, we will have the best possible speakers in the next episodes as well. Starting with Anurag, we will keep on, we'll ensure that we match the same caliber, we match the same intelligence level of what we have seen in this episode, and we would love to take your feedback. You guys can add us on LinkedIn, share your feedback in case if you have any suggestions. We would be more than happy and keen to take it. And a special thanks to the econ team here for helping us manage and organize. God loves you.
1:28:54I think just want to add here, so I truly believe you know you have just witnessed an example of being a seasoned founder. So Koustubh himself mentioned that he doesn't have a channel right now but he's doing this podcast. So that is how you learn from experience. So never be shy of what you want to do, and if you truly believe in it, do jump in, but yes, do your research before jumping in. Perfect. Thank you.